The “Is this a fair trade?” Thread

[ThePaintedPitBull]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69710877&userid=610494&signature=KzeW9Q3xRPryltAI8sQ-Ag

Is this fair??

No, no that is totally unfair to you. The UR Flower Pot is on the main list, where as the dog they are offering is on the Advent List.

[Meridiem]

X

Is this worth the gamble?

[.Animal.]

What list pet could a '08 very rare get? If it would even be fair for a list pet of course.

If this isn't the right place, please tell me so I can go there instead. Or pm me.

[chiamia]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69710877&userid=610494&signature=KzeW9Q3xRPryltAI8sQ-Ag

Is this fair??

No, no that is totally unfair to you. The UR Flower Pot is on the main list, where as the dog they are offering is on the Advent List.

true, unfair to you rarity wise. demand wise however im not sure. I'm not sure if the flower pot has been going for 2 sorbs or more like 1. The White Lolita has pretty good demand and has the potential to trade to a sorb depending on the user.

but I still wouldn't accept, even with demand its a bit of a stretch

The punks with demand, together could go for a sorbet (unless im mistaken)
The CEG goes for a non
3 sorbets = non
1 sorbet + punk dogs = ~~2 sorbets (2/3 of a non)
i'm thinking so that would be almost 2 nons, 1.75

I havent really seen the zonkey go for 3 nons but I guess its possible

their side does (with demand) add up to about a little under
2 nons, depending on what you could get out of the punks.

the zonkey usually goes for 2 to 2.5 nons, and has relatively good demand
compared to the other zebras and such. i would personally say you could
get a bit more out of the little guy, based on personal experience.

thank you ^^ x

[~Loki~]

X

Is this worth the gamble?

No one can say; that’s why it’s called a gamble. It’s if you want to take that chance or not. If they both end up to be nons, then it’s unfair to you. But if one or both are sunjewel then it’s unfair to them.

[sasha.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DnduhdizNQ

what can I add to make this fair?

[plot]

Is this trade fair?

Now unsure
EDIT COMPLETELY MISSED THE PINAPPLE
I was going to say unfair due to Gearback Tribal's demand, however with the pineapple added, I'm unsure of the pinapples demand. Personally, I thought fruits were hard to trade off, but I may be completely wrong! Please check with someone on the pinapple's demand.

[nobxdy]

What list pet could a '08 very rare get? If it would even be fair for a list pet of course.

If this isn't the right place, please tell me so I can go there instead. Or pm me.

Regular '08 very rare pets are only worth 2 '09 rares + a '10 rare. The lowest list pet available is worth 3-4 '09 rares, so it wouldn't be able to get a list pet.

[.Animal.]

What list pet could a '08 very rare get? If it would even be fair for a list pet of course.

If this isn't the right place, please tell me so I can go there instead. Or pm me.

Regular '08 very rare pets are only worth 2 '09 rares + a '10 rare. The lowest list pet available is worth 3-4 '09 rares, so it wouldn't be able to get a list pet.

Thank you for the quick reply!

[chiamia]

Is this trade fair?

Now unsure
EDIT COMPLETELY MISSED THE PINAPPLE
I was going to say unfair due to Gearback Tribal's demand, however with the pineapple added, I'm unsure of the pinapples demand. Personally, I thought fruits were hard to trade off, but I may be completely wrong! Please check with someone on the pinapple's demand.

from personal experience the UR pineapple is pretty hard to trade off for its full value.