The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Tsabhira]

Okay, I sent a trade asking for a 10 commons & uncommons, the rarest (as far as I know) being an Oct. blue moon, offering 2 non-PPSs they posted they were looking for and asking them to edit (since I know I wasn't offering enough). They edit it to this


on their end (same except they removed the blue moon) and

this on my end with the message

"this seems about right to me.

the blue moon I guess I would trade, but not on top of all these. so if you want to remove three or four of these and add the blue moon, that'd be fine. he's awfully sought after right now. :/"


...I'm thinking grossly unfair on my end, since even though the store dogs are still available, they're surely worth more than essentially a few commons.

Could I get another opinion? What would make this fair?

[*~Sharni~*]

Okay, I sent a trade asking for a 10 commons & uncommons, the rarest (as far as I know) being an Oct. blue moon, offering 2 non-PPSs they posted they were looking for and asking them to edit (since I know I wasn't offering enough). They edit it to this


on their end (same except they removed the blue moon) and

this on my end with the message

"this seems about right to me.

the blue moon I guess I would trade, but not on top of all these. so if you want to remove three or four of these and add the blue moon, that'd be fine. he's awfully sought after right now. :/"


...I'm thinking grossly unfair on my end, since even though the store dogs are still available, they're surely worth more than essentially a few commons.

Could I get another opinion? What would make this fair?

The person who owns the store dogs is WAY over paying!

[Vluaaq]

Okay, I sent a trade asking for a 10 commons & uncommons, the rarest (as far as I know) being an Oct. blue moon, offering 2 non-PPSs they posted they were looking for and asking them to edit (since I know I wasn't offering enough). They edit it to this


on their end (same except they removed the blue moon) and

this on my end with the message

"this seems about right to me.

the blue moon I guess I would trade, but not on top of all these. so if you want to remove three or four of these and add the blue moon, that'd be fine. he's awfully sought after right now. :/"


...I'm thinking grossly unfair on my end, since even though the store dogs are still available, they're surely worth more than essentially a few commons.

Could I get another opinion? What would make this fair?

If i were you, unless you were looking for any of those, I'd just cancel it.
if they want that then they probably won't wiggle much.

[Tsabhira]

Okeydokey, thank you both! I am looking for those pets, but not so much as to accept a bad trade.

[Christy]

Whats rarer blue rose or red

[KyoshiYan]

Whats rarer blue rose or red

blue me thinks.

[weby099]

Whats rarer blue rose or red

Blue I believe

[SkySmoke]

Whats rarer blue rose or red

More people look for blue, but i don't know about actual rarity...


I've been offered a yellow toxic OR a black eyed galaxy for my floppy eared tribal. Is either offer fair? Or isn't the floppy worth more?

[Cheetahblaze]

is this a fair trade?
my pets;

the pets being offered;

[KyoshiYan]

Whats rarer blue rose or red

More people look for blue, but i don't know about actual rarity...


I've been offered a yellow toxic OR a black eyed galaxy for my floppy eared tribal. Is either offer fair? Or isn't the floppy worth more?

the galaxy