Equine Transformation Project - VOTING CLOSED

[tacocat.]

I just hope this doesn't end up tearing CS apart. Although seeing all those disrespectful is totally starting to annoy the crap out of me.
Maybe since the designs are Equid's and the lines are Yulynh's, you could add both of their little tag thingies so that Equid isn't forgotten?

[Panne]

Guys please stop being so negative, the staff have been kind enough to color in these pets for us month after month, and more without asking so much as a thank you in return. Now they are offering to redo ALL the old ones, that is a lot of work, and that is a lot of time they are taking out of their days to try and make us happy. You can express your opinion but theres no need to be rude, and post things in your siggy, acting immature.

yes , we should all listen to this . uvu

The whole reason of this thread is to have a debate whether or not to make this pretty big change. They want to make sure that the majority of us are ok with this. There are going to be people who are on both sides of the debate, so naturally there will be comments that can be taken as negative.

I really think some of us are besides the point here. The main point of this change is not to 'hide' anything - It is to keep the site organized, uniform, and just more tidy overall, not to mention items.

I will miss the little PPS horses, but overall I do think this project should be carried out.

[Pangali]

Agree 100% I have never liked the equimagine lineart anyway.

[sydney bee]

I support this - the ponies look nice and those drafts are beautiful <3

[weegeestar5]

I feel that we should keep the old lines to show how much Cs has grown in their years of success. There's been a lot of improvements with everything, but I don't think this should be one of them (no offense at all to Yulynh the new lines are lovely). Sure there were a lot of different line arts for old lines and the items make it hard to dress them up (I think the only thing is the head positioning really), but wouldn't it be easier to alter items instead of putting one design onto another? I don't know that's just me and these are all opinions. I would like it if the old lines would stay though.

I do believe that one of the mods saying it'd be too much trouble to change all of the linearts to fit all of the horse types. c:
Correct me if I'm wrong, though. x3

[jern.]

Guys please stop being so negative, the staff have been kind enough to color in these pets for us month after month, and more without asking so much as a thank you in return. Now they are offering to redo ALL the old ones, that is a lot of work, and that is a lot of time they are taking out of their days to try and make us happy. You can express your opinion but theres no need to be rude, and post things in your siggy, acting immature.

yes , we should all listen to this . uvu

The whole reason of this thread is to have a debate whether or not to make this pretty big change. They want to make sure that the majority of us are ok with this. There are going to be people who are on both sides of the debate, so naturally there will be comments that can be taken as negative.

I really think some of us are besides the point here. The main point of this change is not to 'hide' anything - It is to keep the site organized, uniform, and just more tidy overall, not to mention items.

I will miss the little PPS horses, but overall I do think this project should be carried out.

Its totally fine to have a opinion that is not the same as everyone elses, however there is no need to get nasty, and disrespectful.

[Mavric]

I voted no, for a few reasons:

1. I actually really love the "Arab" lines that Equi had, as well as the first ponies, and I really don't want to see those gone.
2. You're erasing some CS history, and its neat to see how it progressed.
3. It just seems like a discredit to Equi by removing her tag off of her lines and her designs, and placing the yulynh tag on them instead.
4. Same designs, sure, but you're also taking away the uniqueness of the original artist's designs. They lose...something when they're transferred over.
5. Items are easier to convert, and players are very creative when it comes to dressing up their pets anyway.
6. Conversion time takes away from the time that whoever is converting these can use instead to create new pets or otherwise.
7. I'm not fond of the new drafts. The face is too short, and there's something weird going on where the hind leg meets the barrel (like the body needs to be just a touch longer).

As well as some other very good points that a lot of other users are bringing up.

I mostly agree with you excluding #7 there is no way to make every one happy with linearts, anyways with the new draft/other equine linearts we can simply just contine with the traditions of CS with all of our wacjy horses and make new horses!

[Spare]

Guys please stop being so negative, the staff have been kind enough to color in these pets for us month after month, and more without asking so much as a thank you in return. Now they are offering to redo ALL the old ones, that is a lot of work, and that is a lot of time they are taking out of their days to try and make us happy. You can express your opinion but theres no need to be rude, and post things in your siggy, acting immature.

yes , we should all listen to this . uvu

The whole reason of this thread is to have a debate whether or not to make this pretty big change. They want to make sure that the majority of us are ok with this. There are going to be people who are on both sides of the debate, so naturally there will be comments that can be taken as negative.

I really think some of us are besides the point here. The main point of this change is not to 'hide' anything - It is to keep the site organized, uniform, and just more tidy overall, not to mention items.

I will miss the little PPS horses, but overall I do think this project should be carried out.

I agree with all of this! owo ^^^^

[l i v e ♥]

The Equimagine versions were originals - I knew, right when I saw them, that those where Equimagine versions, and that unique style and shape was valuable and cool to me. It's like changing Malk Dogs into the most recent Dog templates - it's just not right. The only thing that would identify them would be the date, rarity and coat (which, honestly, isn't that significant...). Plus, keep in mind all the people who collect those Equimagine horses/ponies! Those poor people could give up those once-special hoards/collections, just because of a template change.

*sigh*

[ohdeer]

I'll miss the old lines, they're a part of history!
are the unicorns going to change too?!

The Equimagine versions were originals - I knew, right when I saw them, that those where Equimagine versions, and that unique style and shape was valuable and cool to me. It's like changing Malk Dogs into the most recent Dog templates - it's just not right. The only thing that would identify them would be the date and the rarity (which, honestly, isn't that significant...). Plus, keep in mind all the people who collect those Equimagine horses/ponies! Those poor people could give up those once-special hoards/collections, just because of a template change.

*sigh*

I totally agree with the hoards and collection problems