I made a document in which to store my personal item values a while ago, and recently reworked it with the help of a few other people in order to release it to the general CS public.
This is relatively preliminary at the moment, so please take that into consideration. Disclaimers are listed on the first page of the spreadsheet, please read them.
TL;DR- Without item rarities, I, nor anyone else could ever make a true estimate of item worth, and thus this is mostly subjective.
This is relatively preliminary at the moment, so please take that into consideration. Disclaimers are listed on the first page of the spreadsheet, please read them.
TL;DR- Without item rarities, I, nor anyone else could ever make a true estimate of item worth, and thus this is mostly subjective.
LINK TO SHEET
FAQ:
PLEASE READ BEFORE MAKING A SUGGESTION OR COMMENTING
PLEASE READ BEFORE MAKING A SUGGESTION OR COMMENTING
How did you come up with these values?
I used equal parts my own experience, what my trading partners wanted as well as what I paid, and the experience of other item experts, many of whom have or had a complete or mostly complete item collection. I also took demand into account, along with objective rarity. Discontinued store items are rarer than free items, item trade-ins are rarer than free items, etc. To a certain degree, I scoured item collections on dead and old accounts to take inventory of their stock.
Where can I find evidence of these values?
I encourage myself and others to use this thread, which lists trades that other uses have done. Many of the recent trades will affirm these values. I also encourage you to contribute your own item trades to the thread if you feel comfortable enough in the valuation of both sides of the trade.
Why do we need a list? How is this going to be helpful?
I 100% understand where you’re coming from. I personally do not subscribe to any particular “lists” as I find trading experience more valuable and reliable. However, I truly believe that items are a special case. As they don’t have rarities, it is incredibly easy to scam an item out of a new user with no experience, and I’ve seen that exact scenario happen a lot. For this reason, I believe it is incredibly important to have some kind of guide for returning users and those who do not often trade for items.
How come this isn’t fully community based?
Because there are so few item experts on CS, I could only find a few users willing to help me on this project, who have the experience and knowledge to put together a guide. I did not use polls as I have found this and seen them used in the past, and they are often inefficient. I would also like to state the opinion that items are such a difficult situation to work with, and again, there are so few users that are truly familiar with them, that I do not feel popular opinion could have the same grasp on these values.
Suggestions? Comments?
PM me or leave them on this thread.
Users I consulted with:
Jacob: Has a full item collection
bakugou: Had a mostly complete item collection. Has been trading for items since 2011.
lucky333123: Has a full item collection
gay (myself): Has a full item collection
These are not all the users I consulted with. It is a list of those who wish to be included publicly on this thread. I will add more users here as I go along and get to talk to them.
Update log:
14th July 2021: Item guide is created
11 Aug. 2021: Item guide is uploaded to CS
12 Aug. 2021: Monster Eyes, 2009 Valentine's, Birthday, and St. Pats. Items are added
21 Aug. 2021: Rat Plushie and Cat Plushie from 2009 Christmas are added
24 Aug. 2021: St Pat's Shoes are added, Raven Perch Order is lowered from .25 to 2 MA, "Unknown" category is added for items with no solid trade data
17 Sept. 2021: 2011 Easter items are added. 2016 space event plant items are added.
30 Sept. 2021: 2009 Halloween Lil Monster, Halloween Candy, Deerskin Outfit items are added.
6 Nov. 2021: Deerskin Outfit re-evaluated.
22 Jan. 2022: Golden Egg Token re-evaluated from 1-2 MAs to LA-MA based on lack of trade data.
23 Jan. 2022: Silly Glasses items re-evaluated from .25 nons to 2 MAs. Raven Perch Order re-evaluated from 2 MAs to 1 MA. Raven Perch re-evaluated from 1 MA to 2 MAs. St. Pat's Shoes re-evaluated from LA to MA. Halloween Lil Monster re-evaluated from '09 rare to LA. '09 CS birthday plushies re-evaluated from MA to LA. Maracas re-evaluated from 1.5-2 MAs to 1.5 MAs. Astronaut Costume re-evaluated from 1 MA to 2 MAs. Werewolf costume pieces re-evaluated from .25 nons each to 2 MAs each. Animal Egg 4 re-evaluated from .5 nons to 1 non. Leopard Plushie re-evaluated from MA to LA. Hammer re-evaluated from .25 nons to 2 MAs.
22 Feb. 2022: Dark Eyes, Slanted Eyes, Collars, Bunny Outfits, and free Christmas Tree Set items are added.
6 Mar. 2023: Laboratory Gas, Malk Fairies, and Eros are added. Values of bunny outfits have been changed to be more clear-cut. Yellow Chicken Suit reduced from 2 MAs to 1 MA.
10 Sept. 2023: Red Rose, Weretomatoes, Count Bunnicula, Medieval Elf Set, and Piranha Set are added.
31 March 2024: Special release items are added.
27 August 2024: Language on sheet is changed. ’09 rare changed to “old rare” and defined. LA changed to .5 MA. Monster eyes value changed from .25 nons each to .5 nons each. Scarecrow Halloween items changed from .25 nons to .5 nons each. Bumblebee Halloween items changed from .25 nons to to .5 nons each. Rapier changed from .5 nons to .25 nons. Jester and Yellow Chicken Suit changed from 1 MA to .5 MA. Maracas changed from 1 MA to .5 MA. Mustache changed from 1.5 MAs to 1.5 MA. Halloween Apples changed from 2 MA-.25 nons to 2 MA. Pink Bunny items changed from 2 MA-.25 nons to 2 MA. Easter Horse Blankets changed from .5 nons to .25 nons. Wizard Token changed from .25-5 nons to .5 nons. Golden Egg Token changed from .5-1 MA to .5 MA. Flower ‘Tail Bracelet’ changed from .25 nons to 2 MA. Heart-shaped Glasses changed from .5-1 MA to 1 MA.
4 December 2024: Snowman Outfit, Snowman Head, and Reindeer Costume are changed from .25 nons to .5 nons each. Holly Fairy pieces are changed from 2 MAs to .25 nons each.
15 April 2025: Special release items are added.
