Is this a Fair Trade? (Dec 18th edition)

[PolarAngel]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85444762&userid=762511&signature=n0nkXbGB8m2ywwIqvTRCjA
Fair?

[ThunderCedar]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85444762&userid=762511&signature=n0nkXbGB8m2ywwIqvTRCjA
Fair?

They are overpaying. The zodiacs are 2010 rares.
Of course, they also are sought after. But demand is subjective and I will leave that part up to you.

[Blure]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85445163&userid=611872&signature=-h9pv8_vb37Ouo4mhuenzw

I have no idea if this is fair?

[ThunderCedar]

Hello again! What does anyone think of this trade?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85420328&userid=837116&signature=by4SMsbnxOn2rOh0aGSt1w

They are overpaying regardless of the outcome you get.
Of course, if you get the shima long-tail, demand would become a factor. But that is subjective and not for me to dictate.
I will say warrior cats are popular as well.

[aloe.]

Could someone check if these are fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85438429&userid=941763&signature=vTAftQEsuBBG1qQjRjtuaQ
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85421276&userid=941763&signature=zWUMxGXqQu6fPMVp4VV3Fw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85440599&userid=941763&signature=kEOOjAejnhmevVw50dW76w

Thanks so much UwU

[aloe.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85445163&userid=611872&signature=-h9pv8_vb37Ouo4mhuenzw

I have no idea if this is fair?

Woah they are massively overpaying you.
I'm not a hundred percent on the rarity and demand of your lion, but it would be on September list at best (probably an advent) and they have offered you a red malk dragon (sept list i believe), a Shima longtail (high in demand), potential Clear or Black eyed galaxy dog (september/main list below gap), as well as a bajillion rares. Please get a second opinion though, as I am unfamiliar with the lion and it could be much rarer than i believe!

[♦【uta】♦]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85445163&userid=611872&signature=-h9pv8_vb37Ouo4mhuenzw

I have no idea if this is fair?

Woah they are massively overpaying you.
I'm not a hundred percent on the rarity and demand of your lion, but it would be on September list at best (probably an advent) and they have offered you a red malk dragon (sept list i believe), a Shima longtail (high in demand), potential Clear or Black eyed galaxy dog (september/main list below gap), as well as a bajillion rares. Please get a second opinion though, as I am unfamiliar with the lion and it could be much rarer than i believe!

that is a high main list im pretty sure the lion is worth 2-3 nons. i dont know how many nons the other side is... but probably not 3

[aloe.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85445163&userid=611872&signature=-h9pv8_vb37Ouo4mhuenzw

I have no idea if this is fair?

Woah they are massively overpaying you.
I'm not a hundred percent on the rarity and demand of your lion, but it would be on September list at best (probably an advent) and they have offered you a red malk dragon (sept list i believe), a Shima longtail (high in demand), potential Clear or Black eyed galaxy dog (september/main list below gap), as well as a bajillion rares. Please get a second opinion though, as I am unfamiliar with the lion and it could be much rarer than i believe!

that is a high main list im pretty sure the lion is worth 2-3 nons. i dont know how many nons the other side is... but probably not 3

Hahaha how did i miss it
It's the UR Lion!!!!!

I am soooo stoopid lol

Yeah, definitely unfair

(Thanks uta)

[♦【uta】♦]

np

[skyline]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85445163&userid=611872&signature=-h9pv8_vb37Ouo4mhuenzw

I have no idea if this is fair?

Woah they are massively overpaying you.
I'm not a hundred percent on the rarity and demand of your lion, but it would be on September list at best (probably an advent) and they have offered you a red malk dragon (sept list i believe), a Shima longtail (high in demand), potential Clear or Black eyed galaxy dog (september/main list below gap), as well as a bajillion rares. Please get a second opinion though, as I am unfamiliar with the lion and it could be much rarer than i believe!

that is a high main list :/ im pretty sure the lion is worth 2-3 nons. i dont know how many nons the other side is... but probably not 3

Hahaha how did i miss it
It's the UR Lion!!!!!

I am soooo stoopid lol

Yeah, definitely unfair

(Thanks uta)

i personally disagree that it's unfair, the ur lion goes for around 1.5 nons, never have i seen or heard of it going for 2 or 3. their side adds up to roughly, at least 1.5 nons, whether the galaxy pup turns into a ceg or beg, both are valued similarly at 1-1.5 nons, the rest of the pets add a decent bit of value on top of that.