December 18th: Is This A Fair Trade?

[Audrey_Bee]

Is this fair?
Also what is the lowest non outcome? And what is the highest?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91617856&userid=997397&signature=N7UEd51boqo1yBZNk2EivA

I would say this is unfair to your side. The lowest possible outcome for your sun pup is a non. Their side doesn’t equal up to that, not even demand wise as far as I am aware. Of course, there’s the possibility of the sun pup becoming a sunback (2-3 nons worth) or a sunjewel (4 nons worth taking demand into consideration). But feel free to get a second opinion:)

[Spiegelriss]

Is this fair?
Also what is the lowest non outcome? And what is the highest?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91617856&userid=997397&signature=N7UEd51boqo1yBZNk2EivA

I would say this is unfair to your side. The lowest possible outcome for your sun pup is a non. Their side doesn’t equal up to that, not even demand wise as far as I am aware. Of course, there’s the possibility of the sun pup becoming a sunback (2-3 nons worth) or a sunjewel (4 nons worth taking demand into consideration). But feel free to get a second opinion:)

I think you‘re ignoring the holly? Cause that can definitely fetch a non
*edit* Don‘t get me wrong, I still wouldn‘t take it if I was you, but to say what they’re offering is not even worth one non is factually incorrect

[TheMightyGooser]

Is this fair?
Also what is the lowest non outcome? And what is the highest?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91617856&userid=997397&signature=N7UEd51boqo1yBZNk2EivA

I would say this is unfair to your side. The lowest possible outcome for your sun pup is a non. Their side doesn’t equal up to that, not even demand wise as far as I am aware. Of course, there’s the possibility of the sun pup becoming a sunback (2-3 nons worth) or a sunjewel (4 nons worth taking demand into consideration). But feel free to get a second opinion:)

I agree, your dog is a very old one, best thing to do is see which one it is of the litter! Then it should be easier to get a grasp of what you want for it

[Spiegelriss]

Which trade is the best for my Sorbet Pup?
Trade 1
Involving Cake Dog, Black Leopard and T7 Dog
Trade 2
Involving Spotted Tribal
Trade 3
Involving Non-Balloon
Trade 4
Involving Oct ´08 Pup

1. their side is about 5-7 mid advents which is what a sorbet is valued at so this would be fair
2 and 3 are fair swaps, just up to you if you prefer one of those pets or your sorbet
4. unfair to you, even the most valuable outcome of the 08 orange oct is only worth a mid advent by rarity

the first three trades are all about worth the same, so it mostly depends if you're looking for quantity/a trade down or just a tier swap

Thank you ^^

[wrath of man.]

Is this fair?
Also what is the lowest non outcome? And what is the highest?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91617856&userid=997397&signature=N7UEd51boqo1yBZNk2EivA

I would say this is unfair to your side. The lowest possible outcome for your sun pup is a non. Their side doesn’t equal up to that, not even demand wise as far as I am aware. Of course, there’s the possibility of the sun pup becoming a sunback (2-3 nons worth) or a sunjewel (4 nons worth taking demand into consideration). But feel free to get a second opinion:)

I think you‘re ignoring the holly? Cause that can definitely fetch a non

hollys dont have the greatest demand. most they consistently fetch is probably .5 a non + toxic

[kyte]

Trade

Is this at least close to fair? ;;

[Audrey_Bee]

Is this fair?
Also what is the lowest non outcome? And what is the highest?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91617856&userid=997397&signature=N7UEd51boqo1yBZNk2EivA

I would say this is unfair to your side. The lowest possible outcome for your sun pup is a non. Their side doesn’t equal up to that, not even demand wise as far as I am aware. Of course, there’s the possibility of the sun pup becoming a sunback (2-3 nons worth) or a sunjewel (4 nons worth taking demand into consideration). But feel free to get a second opinion:)

I think you‘re ignoring the holly? Cause that can definitely fetch a non

I wasn’t ignoring the holly. As far as I have been aware, demand wise too, the holly doesn’t equal up to a non. I have never seen a straight swap. But demand may have changed in the last couple of months, hence why I said to get a second opinion..

[Horror]

Is this fair?
Also what is the lowest non outcome? And what is the highest?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91617856&userid=997397&signature=N7UEd51boqo1yBZNk2EivA

I would say this is unfair to your side. The lowest possible outcome for your sun pup is a non. Their side doesn’t equal up to that, not even demand wise as far as I am aware. Of course, there’s the possibility of the sun pup becoming a sunback (2-3 nons worth) or a sunjewel (4 nons worth taking demand into consideration). But feel free to get a second opinion:)

hollys dont have the greatest demand. most they consistently fetch is probably .5 a non + toxic

they're overpaying if your dog happens to be the nonjewel, but it'll be unfair to you if it's either of the other outcomes

holly seems to be fairly steadily a non at least, and the most recent trade data have all valued it at 1-1.5 non

[Spiegelriss]

-snip-

I think you‘re ignoring the holly? Cause that can definitely fetch a non

I wasn’t ignoring the holly. As far as I have been aware, demand wise too, the holly doesn’t equal up to a non. I have never seen a straight swap. But demand may have changed in the last couple of months, hence why I said to get a second opinion..

When looking at the successful Trade thread it’s definitely been going for 1-1.5 nons

[Demonking Urizen]

What do you think about this trade?
The rat is the Light/Dark Pawprint rat.
I've seen it going for 4 - 6 mid advents and the Grinners seem to fetch 1.5 mid advents as they're true date?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91619458&userid=301251&signature=LLxA-goLR6fhMGE19P5bVg
thank you