So here's the story.
I'd earlier dressed two of my June PPS's (Kummy and Fable) with Puppy Scarf 1, since I had four spare puppy scarves and thought they'd be perfect for them. I planned on later dressing my other two, Wishbone and Tangerine, also (with Puppy Scarf 2), but didn't get around to it until just now. First, I did Tangerine. I put the scarf on correctly, saved it, etc. Then I went to Wishbone's dressup page and found that I had not one but two of the scarves left. So I decided I'd just not saved Tangerine right and would do him again after Wishbone. So I put on his scarf and saved him (after I put on the scarf it went to one scarf remaining), then went to Tangerine's page.
The scarf was on, and the amount of scarves remaining had gone back to two. ><
Thought I should report this.