The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[GhostPants]

2022 star dog store pet set = Evil PPS
crowfeather + graystripe + spottedleaf warriors = Brightheart + 2013 store + ER malk dog + 09 Hyena VR

Any help is greatly appreciated ! <3

@ghostpants

[clarkal]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111186867&userid=343527&signature=4DwUlniv5v-LNa6Ircmiug
How does this look demand wise?

[Llazybonezz]

could i get some help on these, i haven’t played in a bit

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111213149&userid=631866&signature=hGpBJgFMGz9-SlWtS2QWYg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111213163&userid=631866&signature=DS-m6Rz-vTGT8GEVecqo9g

i’m thinking for sure on the second one, and i’m very tempted on the first one but just wanted a second opinion before i accept!

[Ruruskadoo]

Fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111213164&userid=119355&signature=t0tzTT7-ujQssv2BqkDirA

[MrAnkle]

any help with valuing these 09 pets would be awesome!!! ty all!!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111214329&userid=986678&signature=-BQJV2WKRhgC6NAYaw-PIQ

[atlix]

is this trade fair? mine is from 09 and i know is mildly popular so im really not sure

[Unilluminate]

how is this?

im not good with bulk or items but i like the pets offered
theres 185 items on my side

thank you in advance <3333

[answrs]

May I please get opinions on this trade, please? mostly asking about the unicorn vs the fox in terms of trade value/interest, not particularly interested in the horses as trade fodder ^^

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111209549&userid=2710&signature=wxFByr3jZJY5NN93v8nqKA

Or this trade instead, also for the banner hamster:

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111212124&userid=2710&signature=AqsaXLIoGpchvHUGZ2EjCA

(I'm pretty sure the latter is the one I'll go with, and I *think* it's fair if not close enough? but my brain's been scrambled by traveling this week and I figure it can't hurt to ask for another pair of non-jetlagged eyes :'o )

[angst]

could i get some help on these, i haven’t played in a bit

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111213149&userid=631866&signature=hGpBJgFMGz9-SlWtS2QWYg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111213163&userid=631866&signature=DS-m6Rz-vTGT8GEVecqo9g

i’m thinking for sure on the second one, and i’m very tempted on the first one but just wanted a second opinion before i accept!

First looks fair depending on how you count haha and whether you value the basilisk at the low or high end of .25MA (3 vs 4MA) and the cheshire higher than 5MA. Overall though seems to be a solid trade demand and rarity wise (.25non + 2MA = 4-6MA range, cheshire is .5non or around 5MA).

Second seems fair also! 1MA malk elemental TD for the malk valentine's .5MA + robocat .5MA.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111186867&userid=343527&signature=4DwUlniv5v-LNa6Ircmiug
How does this look demand wise?

Looks fair and good! Tribals have fluctuated some though, like for awhile there were trades for them at .25non and not .5non but recent trades seem to be pretty consistent at 5MA/.5non.

If you were really worried you could maybe remove the bun (1MA) and their 09s (2.5 old rares each or .5MA) and just trade 4MA for 4MA valuing the tribal slightly below .5non if your trading partner felt the same, but them adding the extra rares is really nice & thoughtful and valuing the tribal at 4.5MA... so I don't know, it's up to you!

2022 star dog store pet set = Evil PPS
crowfeather + graystripe + spottedleaf warriors = Brightheart + 2013 store + ER malk dog + 09 Hyena VR

Any help is greatly appreciated ! <3

@ghostpants

for the first one it looks like they're just overpaying, I think - I don't think the newer stores quite add up yet + the evil pps is at least 1MA!

the second is so hard hmmm. I feel like your side is solidly 3MA or more if you + your trading partner value TDs highly. their side is 1MA store + brightheart (i've seen her go for 1MA) + malk dog .5MA + AWD at 1-2 09s / 2.5 old rares + an older item that goes for an 09 rare. It's suuuuuper close to being 3MA but I feel like they could throw in maybe an older r/vr or 2 but i may be off! just my two cents! <3

Can anyone help me with these trades?


Trade 1
Trade 2
Trade 3
Trade 4
Trade 5

Thank you for any help!

the link for 2 isn't working for some reason! gives an error, just a heads up!

3 looks like a .5MA swap to me but your pet is a TD, maybe they threw in the extra rares being conscious of that? looks like it sorta depends on how you value TDs but if i'm remembering correctly both pets are in the .5-1MA range here!

4 is interesting, i think i've seen in the successful trades thread people trade the red aussie pps for .5MA, meaning it'd be a solid swap alone for their store. the other pets may be unncessary but i could be wrong!

i'm unsure about the other ones haha hopefully someone will weigh in

[Dappled_pony]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111215614&userid=578819&signature=f6XrovYH29rgNKNCmgGd1Q

please please please please please please help! im not good w egg values!! thanks for any help!!!