The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84871660&userid=815931&signature=ajxJeMe71jbRGFjdsFtDfA
s this fair??? I don't think it is but I want to make sure.

no! a rare is woth 2 uncommons from the same year, those recent VCs are nothing

if you're one of those who values a rare at two uncommons, it'd be overpay for one of the rares but absolutely not fair for both.
to add onto that, a lot of older players (like myself) value a rare as 4 uncommons from the same year. so doubly unfair.

[Katsumi-Luna]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84861203&userid=26641&signature=H6rK0UgKwIVtM0X8R-kBXQ

how does this look? There's 69 pets it but I have more to add if needed?

[glitter]

?

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84861203&userid=26641&signature=H6rK0UgKwIVtM0X8R-kBXQ

how does this look? There's 69 pets it but I have more to add if needed?

very unfair to them.
the raven goes for 2 nons easily.
very roughly, that's about 9-10 mid advent's worth on your side without factoring in demand. personally i think demandwise (and considering the huge bulk here) you could push that to maybe 12-14 mid advents, but that would be up to you and your trading partner. that would cover around enough for a skeleton pps.

just to get to the balloon dog level (one balloon dog = 1/4 of a sorb or 1/8-1/12 of a non, depending on how you value a non) you're looking at adding something in the ballpark of a blue rose' worth (7 mid advents).

[Guest]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84871072&userid=942530&signature=M_20Vw1EQDYkjDrSQiWvCQ

what else would be needed?

i can't tell if that's the full set of warriors off of the top of my head but the full set can go for up to a sorb. i'd value a non at 3 sorbs, personally, so i'd say they need to add another two sorbs' worth of pets at least.

That is not true. I see a full set of warrior cats go for a non like always

[glitter]

?

already accepted the trade but I want to see if it was fair
pls respond its been four pages

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84871072&userid=942530&signature=M_20Vw1EQDYkjDrSQiWvCQ

what else would be needed?

i can't tell if that's the full set of warriors off of the top of my head but the full set can go for up to a sorb. i'd value a non at 3 sorbs, personally, so i'd say they need to add another two sorbs' worth of pets at least.

That is not true. I see a full set of warrior cats go for a non like always

they what
holy moly i just did some digging and oh man that's crazy.
as far as i'm concerned even a sorb is really pushing it

[pluvie]

Does UR shortcake = UR peach??

someone please help I’ve been asking for awhile now :^(

[ArcticDragon]

Hi! I wasn't really sure where to ask this, but I got this trade and I have to ask for what I'd like. I have no idea what these pets are worth as they were new Halloween pets and I'm being asked to trade for non-Halloween ones.

They're asking for 5 token deers, two 4 token butterfly wolf things and a rare from easter.

I've traded with this person a few times before and know they don't really know rarities well, and I don't want to be unfair to either of us. Thank you for the help, and I'm sorry if I should have posted this somewhere else!
Edit for clarity, they're asking me to choose what pets to trade for mine, sorry for the confusion!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84865993&userid=889194&signature=b1ijPUlvaWmw-T44f7kKSA

Edit: I also just got this trade for 8 of the Halloween deer for some very old pets, help would be appreciated for this too!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84871855&userid=889194&signature=E8H1RjrxZWh6heEx1fltgA

[Elwynie]

Does UR shortcake = UR peach??

someone please help I’ve been asking for awhile now :^(

The UR Peach = around 1 non
The Strawberry = 1-2 nons

It would be a fair trade if you or the person you are trading with value the strawberry at 1 non

Hi! I wasn't really sure where to ask this, but I got this trade and I have to ask for what I'd like. I have no idea what these pets are worth as they were new Halloween pets and I'm being asked to trade for non-Halloween ones.

They're asking for 5 token deers, two 4 token butterfly wolf things and a rare from easter.

I've traded with this person a few times before and know they don't really know rarities well, and I don't want to be unfair to either of us. Thank you for the help, and I'm sorry if I should have posted this somewhere else!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84865993&userid=889194&signature=b1ijPUlvaWmw-T44f7kKSA

This is unfair to you
The 2019 rare does not = a 2017 common
There also is a chance that the halloween bwolf and deer could turn rare....so you would be overpaying..for a 2017 common lol