The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Ironic Equation]

could I please get advice on this?
thank you

They're overpaying with the owl; the cat would be a fair swap for your owl

[Strawberry_dreams]

x
x
x

should i take any of these?

in my personal opinion the closest one to fair would be the 2nd one. but I still wouldn't take it. the cerb can go for 2-3 nons but closer to the three side and theirs is worth like 2.5 maybe? the first one is also worth about 2.5-3 nons as the dragon goes for 1.5 and the C$ is about another non-1.5 nons either one is fair so its up to you what you'd like to do. The third one isn't fair as the zebra is about a non then .25 for the apple and 1 MA for the husky.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92485670&userid=623277&signature=zXx_ZgLg78NEH3JP2KJnLg
What does everyone thing about this?
What does the mint Tess horse go for?

breaking this down for you to help with my math as well as explain

the CEG goes for 1.5 nons

the UR mint horse is .5-1 nons but can go for about the middle from what I've seen to 1 non so lets say its .75-1 non
the patchy September is 2 MA
the horse is 1MA
the 2011 store can fetch 1-2MA
the alpacas/llamas are 1 '09 rare+ 1 '10 rare so thats 3 '09 rares for those two
the warrior is about 1-2 '09 rares each so thats 2-4 '09 rares there
the dragon goes for 2-3 '09 rares
4 '09 rares + 1'10 rare for the rest of the stores so this equals about 1.5MA for the other rares
So this is 1.25-1.5 nons depending how you value the horse
The C$ is about 3' 09 rares. so from that I say its about fair. or could be about 22 '09 rares under depending how you value that horse

Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4461620
used this as a source

[LiamTheHedgehog]

I just got this trade recently but I’m not sure if it fair

Here is the trade. It’s a Pet to item trade

[Space Avian]

I just got this trade recently but I’m not sure if it fair

Here is the trade. It’s a Pet to item trade

Your side is 11 2020 items (not including the two free store items)
Items are generally worth an uncommon from their year
In this case yours is worth 11 2020 uncommons

They're offering a 2019 rare (4 2020 uncommons) and a 2019 uncommon (2 2020 uncommons) for a total of 6

They either need to add 5 more 2019 uncommons, or you need to remove 5 items on your side

[kmetott2014]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92459999&userid=18327&signature=BtxOLQIFGrkiBbCM35wPhw

Any help is really appreciated! Thank you 😊

[~Sunlight~]

??? I know nothing about items is this fair?https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92486547&userid=961232&signature=Vf7IhDa_QONOQtkCOdhIdA

[honeycat;]

??? I know nothing about items is this fair?https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92486547&userid=961232&signature=Vf7IhDa_QONOQtkCOdhIdA

wrong link, use the one at the bottom right of the trade ^^

[~Sunlight~]

Help I know nothing about items is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92486547&userid=961232&signature=Vf7IhDa_QONOQtkCOdhIdA

[soma fish]

help trading is the one thing on cs im terrible at :')

[Eagle's Eye]

Help I know nothing about items is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92486547&userid=961232&signature=Vf7IhDa_QONOQtkCOdhIdA

Unfair to you due to the age gap. Your item is from 2014 and is worth at least a '14 common/uncommon