The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[partly cloudy]

was this fair? the growing pup was the rare outcome, not the very rare..

[GhostPants]

^^ Thank you horror!
but now i got another trade on my plate ^^''

they say the angel advent is worth 49 '09 rares, and that what they chose is around 40...
@Gasoline

EDIT: What should i rate this bid? ??/10
EDIT X2: This is my bid for a PPS skele auction. how is it?

[Pacsaj]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... I30TekUJdQ Is this trade fair?? I do not know what the .5 in 1.5 nons would be.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... z6Y_PlTj9Q Is this fair as well?

Please help me!
Please?

[partly cloudy]

Should I accept this?
TRADE

They're overpaying. Not only are they offering you an older store pet, but they've added extra pets as well.

i personally wouldn't accept because '17 store pets go for a late '10 rare. if youd want to swap for one from the same year, then yes it can be a little overpay on their side, but if you dont want a swap then you have a chance at a '10 rare

[AriaHayes]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69915458&userid=42103&signature=31iikn_Hf6G2_3A8Fpxh_Q

[GhostPants]

Should I accept this?
TRADE

They're overpaying. Not only are they offering you an older store pet, but they've added extra pets as well.

i personally wouldn't accept because '17 store pets go for a late '10 rare. if youd want to swap for one from the same year, then yes it can be a little overpay on their side, but if you dont want a swap then you have a chance at a '10 rare

I would accept because 2015-2017 Store pets are ALL worth 2010 rares.

[GhostPants]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69916197&userid=658989&signature=1NIVIATy9ByC20qX9rlaEA
^^ I'm very tempted though I'm not sure if this is fair

very unfair to you.. I dont know how much they'd need to add but they have zero list pets on their side. if anything their side adds up to about a tier 3 List pet... yours is a mainlist.

[Zigzagoon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69916197&userid=658989&signature=1NIVIATy9ByC20qX9rlaEA
^^ I'm very tempted though I'm not sure if this is fair

Very unfair to you, they're not even offering a list pet, and your pet is on the main list. The demand for the pps lion isn't this high at all, I wouldn't take it.

[Woolfyy]

thanks for the help on the other one, how's this one?
how much do they needa add?

edit; how's this demand and rarity wise?
and this? what does the phoenix go for (i'm not too keen on trading my black advent though)

[Pacsaj]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69908131&userid=640488&signature=MeyLpiDXXvHQI30TekUJdQ Is this trade fair?? I do not know what the .5 in 1.5 nons would be.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... z6Y_PlTj9Q Is this fair as well?

Please help me!
Please?

Please help. Thanks very much