The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[EchothroughDarkness]

Are these fair?
What’s is the value of the pets offered?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111251325&userid=410864&signature=kluklnzPUOCsD3xBbHHYxg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111261963&userid=410864&signature=DL5GkADpsCvmPHo-1CCChg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111262482&userid=410864&signature=26I22n0vNnkAHDLsljmxxg

All of these are fair and around 3.5 or a bit more.

Asking another opinion on these.
Plus I got another one, I'm not sure about bulk trades so help needed.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111262978&userid=410864&signature=vcTfhWtKO-17MBVu0De52w

I need this one checked asap, I like it and by my account it looks fair, but I need other opinions

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111271911&userid=410864&signature=rBkVTG630BvOgyoEOx-LWg

[jointedwishes]

Help with this one please? (and ID on the christmas pup, he's a Dec 18th pet so it's throwing me)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111263158&userid=354419&signature=3A2TnDhfLVPtYm_Rr6SJcg

Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4899188&hilit=guide&start=10#p142982164

on horrors list it shows their pps dog as a tier 8

personally, i would take this trade. a 09 vr is worth more (even rereleased) imo, i’m not sure on the demand on your banner pet, but i’d personally give at most a 10’ rare.

most of this is based on my opinion, as i’m not 100% on if the banner pps has a ton of crazy demand.

[Esara]

Hi all! Received this trade for my 2017 store pet. I'm not sure what demand is for this pets they are offering. Thank you!

[squeegi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111266054&userid=929095&signature=AYK61LlbatdfvhSXeodsaQ
how does this look ^_^?

[angst]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111266054&userid=929095&signature=AYK61LlbatdfvhSXeodsaQ
how does this look ^_^?

My understanding is that the kirin goes for 2-2.5nons and the dragon PPS 2-3nons, making this fair. I'd check the successful trades thread if you're worried about the larger range of the dragon to see if it's actually consistently fetching 3nons or not, as I don't think the kirin goes for 3nons at all, but if it seems most trades are around 2-2.5 it looks fair!

Are these fair?
What’s is the value of the pets offered?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111251325&userid=410864&signature=kluklnzPUOCsD3xBbHHYxg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111261963&userid=410864&signature=DL5GkADpsCvmPHo-1CCChg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111262482&userid=410864&signature=26I22n0vNnkAHDLsljmxxg

All of these are fair and around 3.5 or a bit more.

Asking another opinion on these.
Plus I got another one, I'm not sure about bulk trades so help needed.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111262978&userid=410864&signature=vcTfhWtKO-17MBVu0De52w

I need this one checked asap, I like it and by my account it looks fair, but I need other opinions

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111271911&userid=410864&signature=rBkVTG630BvOgyoEOx-LWg

First one is a huge trade, at a glance (I counted but without looking up specific trade data for some of the ERs and vaguely put them at .5MA-ish) looks 3.5nons or more.

Second looks closer to 3nons to me.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111254721&userid=875569&signature=m3HUV2EqR-BIb3ZixiZWww

Please can someone let me know how good this bid is? Thanks 🥰 I'm struggling to work it out 😅

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111257935&userid=875569&signature=bKQ5DqBD05IkoOcfv_khUQ
Just got this one too ☺️[/quote]

I counted possibly over 6MA for the first. The second is a purple toxic which is around the same range, at least 5MA, both are .5nons with the first being worth a bit more. I would get a second opinion though, especially on the first one!

Edit: oops sorry about the bad quoting! Lol

[CloudFyre]

I need this one checked asap, I like it and by my account it looks fair, but I need other opinions

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111271911&userid=410864&signature=rBkVTG630BvOgyoEOx-LWg

I found your pets and here are the names so you can look them up yourself as well if you like:

UR Aussie T2 1N
Nonswirl T2 1N
Null PPS T6 5-7 Old Rares
Purple Sortic T6 5-7 Old Rares
Green Grunge T7 4-5 Old Rares
Lava Lamp PPS T7 4-5 Old Rares
Cloudy Tess Horse T8 3 Old Rares

Store pets
2x 2011 Seahorse 2*2MA = 4 MA
2014 Calgreyhound 0.5 MA
2015 Manticore 0.5 MA

Regular VRs
Blue Tropical Swirl Rat Sept '09
Pink Sparkledog Oct '09
Henna Dreamcatcher April '10
and some regular old rares

So ehh roughly 2.9 nons, something like that. Unless I'm missing something, or perhaps you think the Sortic is a Toxic, seems unfair to you.

[Puddin_Pie]

Please could I get some help with this one?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111265001&userid=242639&signature=JV1QX-raqUvzh5ncIORS0g

They are offering the items.

Any advice on what needs to be added/changed to make it fair if it is not would be most appreciated.

[RaptorWasHere]

is this fair?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111274463&userid=1048629&signature=Jm5Tjn4mxASy9jetF3qHOw

[EchothroughDarkness]

I asked them to edit?
Is it now fair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111272351&userid=410864&signature=pasepSpgMbrS9PVzUMy4Rg

Oh by the way I forgot to say thx to angst for rating my bids.
(This is still one about that auction I am holding)

[angst]

I asked them to edit?
Is it now fair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111272351&userid=410864&signature=pasepSpgMbrS9PVzUMy4Rg

Oh by the way I forgot to say thx to angst for rating my bids.
(This is still one about that auction I am holding)

Oh my goodness... Hahahaha okay so before it was pretty fair, now unfortunately I feel like it's waaaay unfair to them; I counted closer to 7nons worth of pets, double what the offer was before! I feel like maybe 1 or 2 more MA would've put it over the edge but now it's a lot lol. Unfortunately unfair to them; they've got some amazing pets though so you've got a lot to choose from haha. :')

Glad you posted this one! Wishing you all the best in sorting through your bids they're all wonderful.