The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[voe]

Help with this one please? (and ID on the christmas pup, he's a Dec 18th pet so it's throwing me)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111263158&userid=354419&signature=3A2TnDhfLVPtYm_Rr6SJcg

Their pup is a monthly release from December 2009, yours is a banner release from the Halloween candy hunt, more valuable than a token pet or a regular release. I’d say the age gap could make up for the demand difference, as the butterfly pup has that collectible value and good tradability. You should get a second opinion but I think it’s about fair

[Vaal Hazak]

Help with this one please? (and ID on the christmas pup, he's a Dec 18th pet so it's throwing me)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111263158&userid=354419&signature=3A2TnDhfLVPtYm_Rr6SJcg

Their pup is a monthly release from December 2009, yours is a banner release from the Halloween candy hunt, more valuable than a token pet or a regular release. I’d say the age gap could make up for the demand difference, as the butterfly pup has that collectible value and good tradability. You should get a second opinion but I think it’s about fair

I have to admit that I haven't seen the demon banner pps (is it called that?) getting that much of an overpay. the moon dog from the same year, yes. I know that especially the banner pets have started to be more liked and sought after, but from what I know the highest I've seen the pps going for was a 2010 rare.

i've never traded anything above a rare before, just gifted, so i'm a little lost. can anyone help me with this? is it fair?

commonly, a very rare = 2 rares from the same release year, so the deer and the chicken would be fine for the bat, and everything else is just add up.

[Prince of void]

Hey y'all, how could we make this trade even?
Thank you so much
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111236008&userid=200328&signature=govp2DYj8DqijrvTdqaedg

I got offered this trade, would love help making it fair

[Dimmer_Saze]

we're trying to come to a conclusion with this trade! is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111268761&userid=976054&signature=ZApw2nZusdj0kxDQrD-_7Q

[musicgurl333]

we're trying to come to a conclusion with this trade! is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111268761&userid=976054&signature=ZApw2nZusdj0kxDQrD-_7Q

It depends on how you value store pets. IF you value recent store pets as an ‘11 rare, and IF you use the “2:1 rule” then it’s about fair. Personally, I’ve always felt that undervalued store pets.

If you value them just as “old rares”, their side is worth 3 old rares, and your side is worth 4, making it a bit unfair to you.

Personally, I think you could do better with your store pets. If it was me, I wouldn’t accept, but different people value store pets differently.

[coaliev]

I appreciate any help I can get with this trade, thank you in advance! <3

[TooSpooky]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111254721&userid=875569&signature=m3HUV2EqR-BIb3ZixiZWww

Please can someone let me know how good this bid is? Thanks 🥰 I'm struggling to work it out 😅

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111257935&userid=875569&signature=bKQ5DqBD05IkoOcfv_khUQ
Just got this one too ☺️

[EchothroughDarkness]

Are these fair?
What’s is the value of the pets offered?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111251325&userid=410864&signature=kluklnzPUOCsD3xBbHHYxg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111261963&userid=410864&signature=DL5GkADpsCvmPHo-1CCChg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111262482&userid=410864&signature=26I22n0vNnkAHDLsljmxxg

All of these are fair and around 3.5 or a bit more.

Asking another opinion on these.
Plus I got another one, I'm not sure about bulk trades so help needed.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111262978&userid=410864&signature=vcTfhWtKO-17MBVu0De52w

[Kecko]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111260105&userid=37720&signature=GX_VdZ-lCH9Y8SYonI_bow

What would be fair for these items in C$?

[TooSpooky]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111254721&userid=875569&signature=m3HUV2EqR-BIb3ZixiZWww

Please can someone let me know how good this bid is? Thanks 🥰 I'm struggling to work it out 😅

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111257935&userid=875569&signature=bKQ5DqBD05IkoOcfv_khUQ
Just got this one too ☺️