The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[pumpkin_hyena]

I know that older pets are ususlly valued more, but I'm really not sure compared to store pets, so.. could someone take a look at this? Just looking for a second opinion.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111297675&userid=1090308&signature=5K8VpAlpr-EXQTBUgxK60A

[Megavolt]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111297713&userid=835481&signature=nsiDgwXyaAsHDhEJs_QY2w

probably the biggest trade i'll ever do for a while haha. i'd really really appreciate a second opinion before i go for it!

[Konata.]

I know that older pets are ususlly valued more, but I'm really not sure compared to store pets, so.. could someone take a look at this? Just looking for a second opinion.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111297675&userid=1090308&signature=5K8VpAlpr-EXQTBUgxK60A

If the 2013 pet was changed to a 2010 rare then it would be fair

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111297713&userid=835481&signature=nsiDgwXyaAsHDhEJs_QY2w

probably the biggest trade i'll ever do for a while haha. i'd really really appreciate a second opinion before i go for it!

It's actually unfair to you, your side exceeds the worth of 30 old rares (which is what their tess horse is worth)- not to mention theirs is a rr

edit;; im bored ill help with last page

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111294893&userid=755026&signature=NhzuhPxrCTthyRY8lE15UQ

Was this a fair offer not taking demand into account? I am really out of the loop with Lists lately since I don't play that much.

It's fair- both sides are 3 nons worth with demand

Hi, anyone more knowledgeable on the new rarity system than me and could help me with these two trades?
this one and this one, thank you so much!

1st trade; unfair to you- white lolita is worth 1.5 nons and ice cat is 1 non- not sure how much white lolitas go for with demand though

2nd trade; been staring at this for a whilte, feel free correct me if I missed any- their side is about adds up to not even 3 nons worth, which is unfair to you (your lion is 3.5-4.5 nons as a rr)

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111296992&userid=888783&signature=vxtUnnfSdxzKS_CPwOKw9A


any help is greatly appreciated!

I think it's unfair to them, definitely don't think the 2 added recent rares make up for their older pet. dont think your pets have any special demand besides being event pets?

Ellloooo i wanted to ask if this Is fair? thank youu

Actually I think this is a pretty fair trade- I believe their lion is from 2010? A vr + slight add on is fair for your dog

[Megavolt]

thank you immensely! i hope to be able to adjust it.

[uta1911]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111299691&userid=1088985&signature=xtml6sb2HVSF9m3ikcLCcQ

can i get thoughts on this? im not good with lists and store pets. the names of mine were from a previous trade so i really dont know

[sweetpepper]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111299921&userid=763102&signature=s4u87LXjkmfupbkedVSJXA
im unsure on this one and would like some input pls, thank u!!

[SkyBandit]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111300113&userid=774951&signature=kKGdl9jwYXDXybB2FVmczQ


Hello! I was wondering if I could maybe get some help with this trade? Thank you!

[BillyBoi]

Hey guys I have two bids that I’m not 100% sure the value on, I know the first one will be a lil over 1.5Nons from the UR but I just want to know which one would be the better bid as I’d like to put my leading bid up for them to see

1: trades/viewtrade.php?id=111265771&userid=1017560&signature=-Yur0ZBWhVF6ccjjjTUNuw

2: trades/viewtrade.php?id=111290069&userid=1017560&signature=xVV8h0ffySDdkhcU7Np1qw

Hii second opinion here- personally I prefer the first trade as I don't like trading off the list. From my experiences trading bulk rares for lists doesn't really happen unless you find the right players. You're gonna have to trade a lot to work your way back up for list pets (esp since the second trade is offering a lot of more recent rares). If bulk rares is what you're looking for then by all means feel free to rank the bids based off your preferences

Okay thank you!! What about this trade as I’ve noticed a few valueable pets in there? trades/viewtrade.php?id=111297546&userid=1017560&signature=Zllxz4WyO8hxamudstBoiQ

[empanada]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111300268&userid=902493&signature=cEOPKYNWdZKHhFy0Uk45ag

I have not traded rares+ in a long time, is this fair?

[The Ghost Of You]

thoughts on this trade?
not completely sure if their side is under or not

*also just got another trade asking for the exact same pets? uhhh