The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Devik]

Hello! Please could someone help with this trade?
I don't really use C$, so I have no idea about values ^^"
Thank you in advance!

[Audrey_Bee]

Hello! Please could someone help with this trade?
I don't really use C$, so I have no idea about values ^^"
Thank you in advance!

Hi! 2020 rares are valued at 6-7 C$ on horrors list, and 2023 rares at 5C$

So your side is worth 35-40 C$
So it is withing that range, its up to you if you'd rather value them higher on the scale or not:)

[Devik]

Hello! Please could someone help with this trade?
I don't really use C$, so I have no idea about values ^^"
Thank you in advance!

Hi! 2020 rares are valued at 6-7 C$ on horrors list, and 2023 rares at 5C$

So your side is worth 35-40 C$
So it is withing that range, its up to you if you'd rather value them higher on the scale or not:)

Thank you!

[Audrey_Bee]

There are multiple question answered in this post, please check here to see if I've answered your question before re-posting! Thank you !

Hi is this fair or am I overpaying?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111181194&userid=1016753&signature=nkDSCWoD6JS9fQ3I8YTCTQ

Your side is worth 18 old rares and theirs is worth 19 old rares.
As a personal opinion, I would only make this trade if you're looking for the bunnies specifically. With most of them being 2011 (it does count as an old rare but I always personally see it as a slightly lesser version of an old rare) and they're all bunnies which are low demand so you could struggle to make a similar trade if you're not wanting to keep the buns.

That being said, it is fair/slight overpay, so it's up to you if you're happy with the trade !

Thank you!

Youre very welcome ❤️

Just got this bid but I'm not 100% sure on the values, any help is appreciated

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111171834&userid=875569&signature=g-Q4vhR6M4DYNyK7f91GSw

Hi! Their bone pps is 1MA, pink spetember is 2MA and horse is 5-7 old rares ( 0.5-0.7MA)

This Totals to 3.5-3.7 MA

Your C$ is 0.5 nons worth (5MA) so they would need to add another 1.3-1.5MA to make it fair ❤️

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111166119&userid=835481&signature=CG3f0Kd4KjkEbEuwdpmshQ

hi! i dont know how much store pets are worth compared to regular rare pets. what do yall think? thank you for any help!

Hey! So a recent store pet is worth 1 old rare (2010-2011) so your owl would be payment enough for the store pet, everything else is overpay on your end!!

If you want to see store pet values, this is super helpful! It's the table that I use ❤️

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4899188#p142982071

could I have some advice on this
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111171966&userid=1032038&signature=0Cnp9HJHaM4UKwpN_6Ufsg
theres some older pets on their side but I'm not sure what store pets tend to be worth

still looking for advice

They would just need to add one more old rares worth to make it fair! (A 2010 or 2011 rare)

Your 2020 store is worth 2 old rares, the other 2 are worth 1 old rare. The commons look like they're about fair, if not a bit if overpay on their side but not enough for the old rare gap:)

Any help with this?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111156768&userid=191502&signature=q_VE4s5ete7t2bgfuSc0fw

Both the bat and the cat are from the same year, but I don't know how they actually compare to each other.


Also this: trades/viewtrade.php?id=111159859&userid=191502&signature=FflbEEwJWJi7qf0x6RAY3Q
jaybat

The second one would be unfair to you!

There isn't a huge amount of data on the voodoo cats on the successful trades thread, but they do seem to have been trading for around 0.5MA (5 old rares) about a year+ ago.

The top one would be fair in this case as the bat is valued at 5-7 old rares, plus you have the 3 2020 rares so I think it's a good offer if you value the voodoo pps at 0.5MA

If you do choose to accept, I highly suggest posting it to the successful trades thread to help people out with values in the future ! ❤️

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4150112

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111176334&userid=386400&signature=eAuDA5lXjoMJwg2jhwTivQ

Was wondering if I could get help on this! Tysm!

Hi! They'd be overpaying quite a bit!

The manticore pps is valued at 1MA

Their pets are valued at 12 old rares (1.2 MA)
And the eros item is 0.5-1MA

So they're offering 1.7-2.2 MA

just curious if i'm fair for the red cerb been trying to get one for a while so any help is appreciated

That would be quite a lot of overpay for the cerb, actually!

The red cerb is trading for 6-6.5 nons at the moment, and just your 2 pastels and C$ was 7 nons alone. The rest would make it massive overpay ! ❤️

Some people value the pastel at 2.5 nons but even so, that would make it on the far upper side of fair, if not overpay:)

[BeetleDragon]

Just got this trade, I’ve been trying to get rid of the butterfly wolf but I’m not sure if this is fair

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111183043

[_SmollJellyfish_]

Just got this trade, I’ve been trying to get rid of the butterfly wolf but I’m not sure if this is fair

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111183043

wrong link,copy the link under the trade!

[clarkal]

Trade 1:
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111183512&userid=343527&signature=5JiWkjbW0W4fuHN6B3UYLQ

Trade 2:
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111183374&userid=343527&signature=L1ih1p0tosnGZB313U5G1g

I’m lost for the values of these trades, I would love some advice thank you!

[Cunicu]

I'm not really good at calculating worth when it comes to mass trades, so any help with the below would be much appreciated!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111181566&userid=589342&signature=sQrGPGTSxKAfiHFJvTuCpg

[Ediblerock8]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111153693&userid=1054707&signature=i-NEUkit1RtxVZgjgKvgTw

[IconicSpirit]

Hi everyone,
Looking for someone to tell me if this is a fair trade for my skeleton pps:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111177013&userid=1093047&signature=gEtdSGL6x5rt8mIeV2tsVQ

Thanks in advance!