The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Butterfly;]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wGIz9930qg

Help? :3

[Rotzalot]

Hi, I think my trading partner and I asked about this a day or two ago, but didn't get a full explanation as to how and why it was fair/unfair? I'd love another opinion. Thanks anyone who helps. (:
trade.

Second opinion?

[Mewfle]

Hi, I think my trading partner and I asked about this a day or two ago, but didn't get a full explanation as to how and why it was fair/unfair? I'd love another opinion. Thanks anyone who helps. (:
trade.

Second opinion?

I'm pretty sure the sunback's demand has gone down quite a bit now, and from what I'm seeing it's being valued at 3-4 nons c:
The malk can go up to a non with demand, so that's 4-5 nons
And the phoenix itself is worth 1non+ sorbet

Their side is worth 5-6nons + a sorbet, depends on how you value your sunback yourself ^^ The UR tiger seems to go for 7 nons on average, so it's unfair to you by a bit.

Then again, it does depend on how you and your partner value both your sides c:

[snowdrake]

Hi, I think my trading partner and I asked about this a day or two ago, but didn't get a full explanation as to how and why it was fair/unfair? I'd love another opinion. Thanks anyone who helps. (:
trade.

I personally value the sunback at sunjewel tier, so 5 nons. the ur malk at another non and the phoenix doesn't have special demand so I value it at it's real tier: ur cookie dog.
allthogether their side is worth 7 nons + ur butterbun + scarf pps. it's not a bad deal, definitely!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=65238833&userid=858868&signature=DKK2bY4TM5nLwGIz9930qg

Help? :3

perfectly fair!

Need opinons on this one
I'd really like to work something out with them.


Also wondering ...
Would the Green Liontail = Red Grinner be fair?
Or Red Dragon = Red Grinner?
(I'm trying to figure out what would be fair autos if I were to put my grinner up for auction)

not sure about the trade but the autos wouldn't be fair. the pets might be on he same/close to same tier but due to demand the liontails go for a sorbet each. the red dragon can also fetch a high september - low mainlist.

help with these trades please?
cancelled one
two
three

i am terribly inexperienced with list trades, so any help is appreciated. thanks in advance!

personally I'd take trade one. the ur ice cat might not have the best demand but it is definitly not as bad off as the list rat in trade two. I haven't seen the lolita go for that much overpay yet (but then again I was never really interested in it either xD). either way, I definitely wouldn't do trade two. the speckled rats are SO hard to trade off and if I remember correctly they can go for underpay as big as a mid advent. trade three isn't even fair rarity wise.

[l y n n x o]

Clicky!

This? Demand wise? Would you personally accept this? Thank you in advance!!

[snowdrake]

Clicky!

This? Demand wise? Would you personally accept this? Thank you in advance!!

I definitely would! the coontail is worth 2 nons and has average - good demand from my experience. it's perfectly fair and a good trade up!

[azriel]

Is a UR CinnaBun worth a UR Bengal? Thanks in advance!

[Yooyu]

Is this fair? Thank you!

[bear]

Is this trade fair?
If not, what would have to be added/removed? I'm not planning on removing any of the rabbits.
Thanks in advance!

[snowdrake]

Is this trade fair?
If not, what would have to be added/removed? I'm not planning on removing any of the rabbits.
Thanks in advance!

unfair to you. your 2009 rare alone is worth 256 '15 commons.