The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[i n f i n i t e]

Which of these is the most fair? (Auction Bids)
1
2
3

Personally, (well.. they're all overtrades) I like the first bid cuz of the super cute dragon and I think it's the one that's offering the most. If you like trading down in rarity then I suggest you accepting the second trade, but if you like trading up in rarity I suggest you accept the first. Trust me Emai.. x3

Thing is, the dragon looks kinda weird in my opinion... Im not sure if it would be easy to trade off.

I would accept the 2nd trade. It's more overpay than the rest.

[mooney]

Which of these is the most fair? (Auction Bids)
1
2
3

Personally, (well.. they're all overtrades) I like the first bid cuz of the super cute dragon and I think it's the one that's offering the most. If you like trading down in rarity then I suggest you accepting the second trade, but if you like trading up in rarity I suggest you accept the first. Trust me Emai.. x3

Thing is, the dragon looks kinda weird in my opinion... Im not sure if it would be easy to trade off.

bid 1 is offering a late 2010 rare + some (the recent pets aren't worth a lot in this trade and don't really make a difference)
bid 2 is offering two and a half 09 rares
bid 3 is offering two 09 rares

so overall, bid two is the one worth the most. the "weird dragon" is a store pet from 2014 and tends to be pretty easy to trade off in my experience, as store pets in general are very liked.

[oblivionis]

me again, fair?

[Fwutter]

Which of these is the most fair? (Auction Bids)
1
2
3

Personally, (well.. they're all overtrades) I like the first bid cuz of the super cute dragon and I think it's the one that's offering the most. If you like trading down in rarity then I suggest you accepting the second trade, but if you like trading up in rarity I suggest you accept the first. Trust me Emai.. x3

Thing is, the dragon looks kinda weird in my opinion... Im not sure if it would be easy to trade off.

I would take the 2nd trade. Yes they are all unfair to the top, but a 2008 pet + 2 warriors for your zodiac seems fair to me demand wise. This is because the warriors and zodiacs have almost the same type of demand. I personally think warriors have higher demand, so saying this the 2nd trade is your best bet. I would have to disagree with @watery>~< on the first trade being the one you should take. The dragon store pets have some what decent demand ((not including the dragon pps)) and I've seen them go for more than what they are worth. Honestly I don't think you trading that red store dragon cat for a zodiac dog it would be accepted. So I highly suggest you choose the 2nd one. Also rats ((going for the third trade)) have very low demand and is hard to trade off.

[RiN_X04]

Which of these is the most fair? (Auction Bids)
1
2
3

Thank you! Any more opinions? Please try to factor in demand :3

[oblivionis]

me again, fair?

[Horror]

Which of these is the most fair? (Auction Bids)
1
2
3

Thank you! Any more opinions? Please try to factor in demand :3

Demand varies from person to person, not everyone values pets the same c:

First trade is worth about an 09 rare more or less.
Second trade is worth 2 09 rares + an '11 rare.
Last one is 2 09 rares.
I'd personally take the second. Valuing a zodiac @ a mid 09 rare, the first trade is about fair & the others are overpay, with the second being worth just a bit more. There's also one warrior in the second trade, so if you like warriors then it's a pretty good deal as well. I personally don't like warriors, but I'd take that trade nonetheless.

[mooney]

Which of these is the most fair? (Auction Bids)
1
2
3

Personally, (well.. they're all overtrades) I like the first bid cuz of the super cute dragon and I think it's the one that's offering the most. If you like trading down in rarity then I suggest you accepting the second trade, but if you like trading up in rarity I suggest you accept the first. Trust me Emai.. x3

I would take the 2nd trade. Yes they are all unfair to the top, but a 2008 pet + 2 warriors for your zodiac seems fair to me demand wise. This is because the warriors and zodiacs have almost the same type of demand. I personally think warriors have higher demand, so saying this the 2nd trade is your best bet. I would have to disagree with @watery>~< on the first trade being the one you should take. The dragon store pets have some what decent demand ((not including the dragon pps)) and I've seen them go for more than what they are worth. Honestly I don't think you trading that red store dragon cat for a zodiac dog it would be accepted. So I highly suggest you choose the 2nd one. Also rats ((going for the third trade)) have very low demand and is hard to trade off.

the 2008 pet had an extended release and is worth a mid 2009 rare (August 09) - but I do agree with everything else you said. as I stated, bid 2 is offering the most c:

[pink_fate]

Which of these is the most fair? (Auction Bids)
1
2
3

Thank you! Any more opinions? Please try to factor in demand :3

I'd say the most fair it's the second one, they got a 2008 and a 2009 rare! Also the sitting cats from 2008-2010 are very popular,

[dibidibidis]

Is this fair?
Link
I know the Basilisks have demand as they're list store pets, but I have close to zero experience with trading sitting cats so I'm not sure the extent of their demand.