The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SmolDrago]

Can i have some help on this trade? thank you!

Definitely overpay on the side with more pets. The value of all the pets they ask for probably about equals the value of the store pet (1 new (likely) rare or EUC, 2 old EUCS, 1 2017 EUC = 1 old-ish rare more or less) and everything else is extra, especially since they have two+ token pets it looks like (and the rat will most likely turn out to be rare even if the others turn out to be EUC)

[Izzy289]

Screenshot 2024-03-30 at 2.19.41 am.png (151.12 KiB) Viewed 114 times

Screenshot 2024-03-30 at 2.19.46 am.png (194.32 KiB) Viewed 114 times

hi someone offered me this horse for my cat. is this fair?

[hinata]

is thisa fair trade? if not, how could i make it more fair?

[GhostPants]

Help <3?
@ghostpants

[Beta]

Help is this fair?

[~SNCastiel<3~]

Screenshot 2024-03-30 at 2.19.41 am.png

Screenshot 2024-03-30 at 2.19.46 am.png

hi someone offered me this horse for my cat. is this fair?

That's very much over paying on the horses side.

[FauxFeather]

I need advice on these trades:
1.i know it's overpay(?) but i feel iffy about it (2010 rat for bulk pets)

2. egg 106 for my 116

3. Multiple items and eggs for my eggs (among which are egg 87, 89 and 40 on their side)

4. Pets + items and egg 108 for 112


Thanks in advance :3 !!!

I still need help!!

Thank you in advance <333

[bohnette.]

They are also asking if this is fair, I'm assuming no because of the year gap but I'd like more insight(: ty in advance.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110661940&userid=308741&signature=qvdTt0evk2um4qsDI9pkuQ

[⋆✰ Dragon ✰⋆]

Would this be fair? I know animal eggs go for a bit but I'm not sure how much ^^;

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110558424&userid=997302&signature=J6auOOPu16hiUN2c1guOtA

Bumping this!

[SmolDrago]

They are also asking if this is fair, I'm assuming no because of the year gap but I'd like more insight(: ty in advance.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110661940&userid=308741&signature=qvdTt0evk2um4qsDI9pkuQ

Usually older pets with the same rarity as a newer pet are still treated as more valuable, since a lot of them are locked in the accounts of older players who don't play or trade anymore. You could ask for another couple VUCs or EUC to make it more fair to you