The “Is this a fair trade?” Thread

[Softea]

Is this a fair trade?
Thank you!

[Constellation.]

Back again! The third trade added and now I'm stuck.

WARNING: LARGE QUANTITY (of rares) IN THESE

Trade one
Trade two + This + This

They added more rares and lists. Again considering all pets will be sold for C$ (but the lists will be traded down and then sold for C$), which one is best? (:

Thanks! (: Second opinion? Added again.

[Coleslaw]

trade

would this be considered a good bid for the '08 Halo?

thank you in advance!

Their side is worth about a blue rose or 6-7 mid advents. I’d say that’s a solid bid ✌🏼

[Horsefreak]

Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6
Bid 7

Should I accept any of these? if so which one

The lion is worth around 1.5 Nons (a non + sorbet ish), the only bid that makes it there (and over) is the banana. The rest come no where close, or (the non bid + ur flower pot bid) come close but need a little bit more to be fair. The flower pot has demand that brings it lower right now though, so it’s between the noncoon and the banana.
The banana is worth around 2 Nons, but demand is so-so.

So would you recommend I cancel these? or accept the banana trade?

Personally, I would accept non of those. While the banana is overpay, it's demand is bad and often bring less than a non.

[Trickz]

Red Toxic = Blue Balloon + Pink Balloon

Is this fair, or does someone need to add?

At least one more opinion please c:

[pigeon -]

running an auction for off-list and wondered which would be the fairest? thanks!
one ; two

[popping star]

Are either of these fair?
1
2

[torbie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70122187&userid=896200&signature=U4Awk9c1ZhqONhM25kH9fg
Is this fair?

very unfair to you — 1 ‘09 rare alone is overpay for the fox

thanks, second opinion?

[atreyu]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70122237&userid=656649&signature=eokGkMteM_3Q3ZiAdZefPA

Would this be fair?

Could I get at least two opinions?

[Coleslaw]

Is this a fair trade?
Thank you!

100 C$ is a high advent, they’re completely overpaying.
But however you see the demand for the cat is up to you. Also the C$ is hard to trade for pets so if that’s what you plan to do with it, I’d keep the cat and try to get those pets with it instead of C$

running an auction for off-list and wondered which would be the fairest? thanks!
one ; two

The second is worth a little over 4 mid advents which is overpay for the scarf PPS, but the first one is a broken link uwu