*DISCONTINUED* Rares List Guide (1 March 2019)

[LLHBBB]

I had hoped discussion would perhaps spark again but.. Course of action?

Move the peach to ur lion
Start discussion on skelebun?

Agree\disagree?

I agree also

[The Last Raven]

I had hoped discussion would perhaps spark again but.. Course of action?

Move the peach to ur lion
Start discussion on skelebun?

Agree\disagree?

Agree

[~GirlsDeMo~]

I had hoped discussion would perhaps spark again but.. Course of action?

Move the peach to ur lion
Start discussion on skelebun?

Agree\disagree?

Agreed.

As for the store pet based list I do think that'd be quite a good idea, since store pets are a speciality and should be treated as such. Though how would their values be termed per say? Like we know on the current list the Red Cerberus is listed as being worth two mid-advents or a low&high advent list. But on a store pet specific list how would it be termed and arranged?

[DaDwarf]

I dont think discussion should be heading where its heading now. The rarity only list will take care of store pets, making a seperste list now will be a lot of work and will mean not adding/moving the skelebun to where it belongs while it needs to be moved.

Lets focus on actually placing pets rather then all these other ideas. We can always go back to working out these ideas after we finish placing and moving pets that need to be..

We know that rarity wise, the skele bun is worth more then a coontail dog, purely looking at rarity. So i think between coon and dogtag tier somewhere wouldnt be a bad spot. Trades right now are super overpay because demand so i feel like somewhere around there would be more then fair for now.

(Can someone copy the archive image link of the peach for me, special release 2015, i somehow cant get it to work on my ipad.)

[ratonhnhaké:ton]

I dont think discussion should be heading where its heading now. The rarity only list will take care of store pets, making a seperste list now will be a lot of work and will mean not adding/moving the skelebun to where it belongs while it needs to be moved.

Lets focus on actually placing pets rather then all these other ideas. We can always go back to working out these ideas after we finish placing and moving pets that need to be..

We know that rarity wise, the skele bun is worth more then a coontail dog, purely looking at rarity. So i think between coon and dogtag tier somewhere wouldnt be a bad spot. Trades right now are super overpay because demand so i feel like somewhere around there would be more then fair for now.

(Can someone copy the archive link of the peach for me, special release 2015, i somehow cant get it to work on my ipad.)

link to the peach
as for the skelebun, i feel like the ur cat would be a good tier, mostly because i think it's probably rarer than the cucumber and banana (and definitely has more demand) due to it being a store pet and not being rereleased.

[ElementalInsanity]

I had hoped discussion would perhaps spark again but.. Course of action?

Move the peach to ur lion
Start discussion on skelebun?

Agree\disagree?

Agree

Also agree.

As far as placing for skelebun I'll just stalk discussion for now as I have no opinion as of yet.

[myth;]

link to the peach
as for the skelebun, i feel like the ur cat would be a good tier, mostly because i think it's probably rarer than the cucumber and banana (and definitely has more demand) due to it being a store pet and not being rereleased.

I still think that's too low, it's been nearly a year since the bunny turned OMGSR and a lot of users have joined and more pets been adopted, at the least it should be at the dog tag tier, if not higher.

Also, what would pet/s would be considered as 1/3 of a sorbet? :\

[Sinbreaker]

Disagree.

If we're going to ignore the input of the community with the poll, then why even have one?
UR Holly tier is the most popular. The Lion tier actually has the least amount of votes.

[myth;]

Disagree.

If we're going to ignore the input of the community with the poll, then why even have one?
UR Holly tier is the most popular. The Lion tier actually has the least amount of votes.

The theory behind that is because people have been told the peach is only worth 2 sorbets for weeks because of a rumour, but we have hard proof it trades for far more than that. If we were to ask the community the true value of the BA for example, more than half would put it at a sorbet because that's what they've been told. And if people don't want to trade 1 non for it, then that's their opinion. The list is just a guide after all.

[.muse.]

Disagree.

If we're going to ignore the input of the community with the poll, then why even have one?
UR Holly tier is the most popular. The Lion tier actually has the least amount of votes.

The theory behind that is because people have been told the peach is only worth 2 sorbets for weeks because of a rumour, but we have hard proof it trades for far more than that. If we were to ask the community the true value of the BA for example, more than half would put it at a sorbet because that's what they've been told. And if people don't want to trade 1 non for it, then that's their opinion. The list is just a guide after all.

That doesn't change that what Sin said was right. The Ur Lion option has the least amount of votes. So it would be pretty pointless to have ran the poll, and then go with the least voted option regardless.
Rumors aside, if the poll is indeed to be disregarded, why jump to the highest value of placement and not settle on the middle ground at the very least?

Edit: I didn't pay anywhere near a non for my peach, I would have to add up the value of what I paid, but the highest list pet on my side was a green toxic, followed by grinners being the next most valuable. I honestly don't see the peach as being worth more than a non. Maybe equal, more likely less, but more than seems like a far stretch.