The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[pup909]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... qT3ducwVBA
Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SJJcEwyNEA Also this

second is more fair to you but less fair to them and first is the opposite due to the pet on their side being a main list

Thank you! Second opinion? Please? c:

[zenzi]

So which would be more fair? For whatever reason the Timberwolf advent has a decent amount of demand. So I have no idea why these people would want to trade down but... who knows lol.

I have an auction and am debating between these two trades? Which is.. well, not necessarily more fair, but better?

This one
Or
This one?

Please and thanks <33

well personally id go with the 2nd one considering sitting cats already have good demand + its a list pet. Hollyfox cats can sometimes fetch a bit of overpay with patience..but get a second opinion on that

Cool, thanks! Second opinion? <3

the second offer is a bit better than the first, it's offering a few '09 rares more (:

[GhostPants]

^^ Thank you horror!
but now i got another trade on my plate ^^''

they say the angel advent is worth 49 '09 rares, and that what they chose is around 40...
@Gasoline
EDIT: Would a Shima BW+ Snowflake BW+ White tinsel horse = sorbet(???)

[puffy]

is a pink sorbet a fair trade for a ur bengal?

[~Loki~]

This is overpay List-wise, but what about demand? Pretty sure it’s still unfair to them but I’d like to be sure.

demand wise the aussie will at least go for a non (based on personal experience) -- but please get another opinion before making a final decision!

Thank you! Second opinion please?

[zenzi]

EDIT: Would a Shima BW+ Snowflake BW+ White tinsel horse = sorbet(???)

can't answer the first part since it's my trade lol
that would be worth a bit more than a skeleton pps, so you'd still need to add a gearback tribal or so.

[CreamyFloof]

Fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1Ws84iVm-w

[GhostPants]

EDIT: Would a Shima BW+ Snowflake BW+ White tinsel horse = sorbet(???)

can't answer the first part since it's my trade lol
that would be worth a bit more than a skeleton pps, so you'd still need to add a gearback tribal or so.

alright! thank you very much )

[Pacsaj]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... I30TekUJdQ. Is this trade fair?? I do not know what the .5 in 1.5 nons would be.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... z6Y_PlTj9Q Is this fair as well?

[iriskai]

Is this a fair trade?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69905090&userid=245962&signature=_rZGav9VnX2XR1LHKtYn6w

unfair to them by a bit more than an '09 rare
i wouldn't take it though, the stores have pretty good demand and can fetch more overpay than that (:

Thank you!! Super helpful, I appreciate it! Thoughts on what could be added to their side to make it fair?