[CS Items Popular Values Guide]

[8catpaws]

Either I’m blind, or the Elven Set from the 2011 Summer event is not listed. I’ve had 2 full sets since 2011, and I remember them being Auctioned for closet to MA over the years. I’m trying to find trade data rn, but it was brought to my attention as someone tried to offer a mega trade for just the earrings from me, but I turned them down as I didn’t want to break my sets up

[teddy]

Either I’m blind, or the Elven Set from the 2011 Summer event is not listed. I’ve had 2 full sets since 2011, and I remember them being Auctioned for closet to MA over the years. I’m trying to find trade data rn, but it was brought to my attention as someone tried to offer a mega trade for just the earrings from me, but I turned them down as I didn’t want to break my sets up

Each piece is an ‘09 rare each.

[Animall]

Either I’m blind, or the Elven Set from the 2011 Summer event is not listed. I’ve had 2 full sets since 2011, and I remember them being Auctioned for closet to MA over the years. I’m trying to find trade data rn, but it was brought to my attention as someone tried to offer a mega trade for just the earrings from me, but I turned them down as I didn’t want to break my sets up

Each piece is an ‘09 rare each.

Are there any plans to update the chart? There seems to be a lot of stuff missing.
I was also looking for the valentines rose from 09 and its not listed either, and its been trading for a low-mid advent for a while.

[teddy]

Either I’m blind, or the Elven Set from the 2011 Summer event is not listed. I’ve had 2 full sets since 2011, and I remember them being Auctioned for closet to MA over the years. I’m trying to find trade data rn, but it was brought to my attention as someone tried to offer a mega trade for just the earrings from me, but I turned them down as I didn’t want to break my sets up

Each piece is an ‘09 rare each.

Are there any plans to update the chart? There seems to be a lot of stuff missing.
I was also looking for the valentines rose from 09 and its not listed either, and its been trading for a low-mid advent for a while.

Is there anything else besides the rose you'd like to see added?

[8catpaws]

Either I’m blind, or the Elven Set from the 2011 Summer event is not listed. I’ve had 2 full sets since 2011, and I remember them being Auctioned for closet to MA over the years. I’m trying to find trade data rn, but it was brought to my attention as someone tried to offer a mega trade for just the earrings from me, but I turned them down as I didn’t want to break my sets up

Each piece is an ‘09 rare each.

Are there any plans to update the chart? There seems to be a lot of stuff missing.
I was also looking for the valentines rose from 09 and its not listed either, and its been trading for a low-mid advent for a while.

Is there anything else besides the rose you'd like to see added?

I believe at this point based on observing the lost and found thread as well as questions I’ve read here, if there was a way to add most of the items up to 2011 that aren’t store items that would be helpful. Most questions in my passing view seem to pertain to that time frame of items.

As my post is the start of this particular thread of conversations, I will offer I have some background on this subject since I’ve been prioritizing item collection since I joined in 2011. I may not have a complete collection, but I am available for help with this topic if y’all want another perspective for items older than 2015 :3 I saw this rarity guide in passing which is why I asked about the set tbh because I was curious :3

[~SNCastiel<3~]

Mark

[Animall]

Are there any plans to update the chart? There seems to be a lot of stuff missing.
I was also looking for the valentines rose from 09 and its not listed either, and its been trading for a low-mid advent for a while.

Is there anything else besides the rose you'd like to see added?

Sorry for the late response -- I totally got sidetracked by the CS drama and forgot to reply here, lol.
To keep it concise; I really feel as if all of the limited store items need to be added, as long as there is proof they trade for at least an '09 rare each. Ive found that most limited store items/sets as late as 2022 are hard to find and popular enough to boost their value.

I am under the opinion that, because items do not get rereleased, that later years items shouldve gained value by now. Some early items I feel are worth adding now include, but may not be limited to; the '09 lipstick kiss, '09 red rose, '10 penpens, '10 piranha fins/teeth/tail, and possibly weretomatoes. I think a lot of items from Easter/Halloween/Christmas from the years 2008-2011 should be considered to be added. I dont have any proof on-hand for this though beyond being an old member that is semi-collecting items.

[teddy]

Are there any plans to update the chart? There seems to be a lot of stuff missing.
I was also looking for the valentines rose from 09 and its not listed either, and its been trading for a low-mid advent for a while.

Is there anything else besides the rose you'd like to see added?

Sorry for the late response -- I totally got sidetracked by the CS drama and forgot to reply here, lol.
To keep it concise; I really feel as if all of the limited store items need to be added, as long as there is proof they trade for at least an '09 rare each. Ive found that most limited store items/sets as late as 2022 are hard to find and popular enough to boost their value.

I am under the opinion that, because items do not get rereleased, that later years items shouldve gained value by now. Some early items I feel are worth adding now include, but may not be limited to; the '09 lipstick kiss, '09 red rose, '10 penpens, '10 piranha fins/teeth/tail, and possibly weretomatoes. I think a lot of items from Easter/Halloween/Christmas from the years 2008-2011 should be considered to be added. I dont have any proof on-hand for this though beyond being an old member that is semi-collecting items.

10 Sept. 2023: Red Rose, Weretomatoes, Count Bunnicula, Medieval Elf Set, and Piranha Set are added. I will not be adding the recent limited items to the spreadsheet until I can find a consensus on what they are each worth.

[bellatrix743]

This is so so helpful! And so relieving to see it's up to date/not really old and hasn't been considered! I hope it's okay for me to than you!

Also a question: Is the ring toss token worth anything? (Or a 2011 uncommon)

[teddy]

This is so so helpful! And so relieving to see it's up to date/not really old and hasn't been considered! I hope it's okay for me to than you!

Also a question: Is the ring toss token worth anything? (Or a 2011 uncommon)

Extremely common, not worth anything really.