The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[angelfangs]

is this a fair trade for my re-release? tbh i have no clue what mine is worth, but i rly like the 2 pets being offered

[jointedwishes]

store pet help!!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111200933&userid=961979&signature=3Lf5ct19zKl_bl6r2t6maw

horrors list values amber pps lion it at .5ma, but I've been trying to surf through completed trades, and i've seen some people value it at 1ma? is this a fair swap or should i request a second one?

[Ghoulls]

is this a fair trade for my re-release? tbh i have no clue what mine is worth, but i rly like the 2 pets being offered

This is very unfair to you. Your pps dog is a 2013 Halloween rerelease, so you could definitely get much more for it. Both of their pets are from the Easter events in 2023 and 2024

[Supreme]

Can someone help me with this trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111188517&userid=702384&signature=8kQ34ZBpZmWaKHyj8saEyQ

[musicgurl333]

link to trade

obviously this isn’t fair but i want to offer them something fair for JUST the VR kitty on their side possibly since i don’t mind trading some of these event pets away. roughly what would be fair for the 2016 VR cat? i don’t care if it’s slightly unfair to me, just want to make sure it’s good for them! thanks in advance!

If you use the old “2:1 rule” (which I do not recommend), then one of your ‘14 rares would be plenty.

If you use the “3 year rule”, then 2 of your ‘14 rares would be fair.

[Never & Rush]

link to trade

obviously this isn’t fair but i want to offer them something fair for JUST the VR kitty on their side possibly since i don’t mind trading some of these event pets away. roughly what would be fair for the 2016 VR cat? i don’t care if it’s slightly unfair to me, just want to make sure it’s good for them! thanks in advance!

If you use the old “2:1 rule” (which I do not recommend), then one of your ‘14 rares would be plenty.

If you use the “3 year rule”, then 2 of your ‘14 rares would be fair.

yeah i find the 2:1 rule a little silly with rares+, i’ve never thought it made sense to value them that way. thanks so much!

[catavamp]

Pets for retired store jackets?
Not sure about this one Would it be fair or over trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111199212&userid=547698&signature=EPFUv6Z-_Ey29F6aPnMZ_Q

[Lunarsnow]

If anyone wants to take a peek at this large huge bulk rare trade for the ur bengal as a second set of eyes it would be much appreciated! It was sent as a suggestion and I'm still picking through it myself before I send it back to them
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111190895&userid=626333&signature=Bzpp5XtOhwLW8hs_YE2y2Q
I completely understand if no want wants to tackle it haha

[Jaybat]

Any help with this?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111156768&userid=191502&signature=q_VE4s5ete7t2bgfuSc0fw

Both the bat and the cat are from the same year, but I don't know how they actually compare to each other.


Also this: trades/viewtrade.php?id=111159859&userid=191502&signature=FflbEEwJWJi7qf0x6RAY3Q
jaybat

The second one would be unfair to you!

There isn't a huge amount of data on the voodoo cats on the successful trades thread, but they do seem to have been trading for around 0.5MA (5 old rares) about a year+ ago.

The top one would be fair in this case as the bat is valued at 5-7 old rares, plus you have the 3 2020 rares so I think it's a good offer if you value the voodoo pps at 0.5MA

If you do choose to accept, I highly suggest posting it to the successful trades thread to help people out with values in the future ! ❤️

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4150112

This is super helpful, thank you! I was already leaning towards the top trade (cat and bat are from the same event, etc), but I wasn't sure about the 2009 in the second trade.

Also noted about the successful trades thread. I keep forgetting that exists. Again, thank you!

[~Bai~]

Is this fair? Thanks in advance for any help