The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Delest Wolf]

Hey there! Me again, the not so new newbie haha! I received this trade and my gut is telling me that my side is overpay. I'm not sure how high in demand the longma is compared to the basiliks and seal pps, taking the fact that they're store pets into mind and it's the whole basilik set. I know the peas don't have the best demand. Help!!

Click!

store pets will always go up in value, whilst urs will either maintain their current value or drop, rarely rise unless there is an odd demand spike. as such most people prefer to trade their stores for other stores, whether up or down the store list, or go for overpay
that being said, the basilisks are worth 3-4 ma each, seal is worth .75 non, the pink dog is .5 ma, peas are .5 non, and zombie horse is 1 ma. you would be overpaying by 3-6 ma, not accounting for store demand.

Thank you so much for your help. I sent this trade back to them. The trade was originally at a 19-19.5 MA worth before I sent this specific one, so I sent this one over. My trading partner stated they value the longma at 21-23 MA, which I think is overall fair in my honest opinion. Is this trade I sent back within the 21-23 MA range? I don't mind overpaying just a bit considering it's a trade up.

[sweetpepper]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111475061&userid=763102&signature=SixFErDU7UBvUxWdRH_KBg
would this be fair for my cheetah? ty for any input! ^^

[ashers_aether]

i’m worried i’m losing out on this trade, and along with that i would want to edit it anyways because i prefer some of the designs on my side, any advice on how much my side is worth would be super helpful! thank you :]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111477293&userid=940863&signature=XTguEc21yxBeH0KvnLT4vQ

[Mintleaf2]

i’m worried i’m losing out on this trade, and along with that i would want to edit it anyways because i prefer some of the designs on my side, any advice on how much my side is worth would be super helpful! thank you :]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111477293&userid=940863&signature=XTguEc21yxBeH0KvnLT4vQ

Butterfly wolf side is overpay IMO. The snakes are cool but none of them are particularly valuable. A true date very rare from 2009 plus a VR rerelease is insane for what they're asking for in my opinion

[igmatic]

Hi! Does anyone know if this is a fair trade? I fear that I might be overpaying, but if not I'd like to know =] ty!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111477587&userid=1014023&signature=1cCFkE0S-E-QJM4SsDz-yw

[Willow.cat]

Hi! Does anyone know if this is a fair trade? I fear that I might be overpaying, but if not I'd like to know =] ty!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111477587&userid=1014023&signature=1cCFkE0S-E-QJM4SsDz-yw

The other side is definitely way overpaying, your side is all low rarity/recent and theirs has a store pet worth a 2010-2011 rare!

[igmatic]

Hi! Does anyone know if this is a fair trade? I fear that I might be overpaying, but if not I'd like to know =] ty!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111477587&userid=1014023&signature=1cCFkE0S-E-QJM4SsDz-yw

The other side is definitely way overpaying, your side is all low rarity/recent and theirs has a store pet worth a 2010-2011 rare!

I did not notice that, tysm!! :]

[natureførest]

Hi, is this fair? Thanks for any help! <3


trades/viewtrade.php?id=111470858&userid=819780&signature=Toc9NGLNQslZPRkaC05z1g

[Zoethian]

Hiya!
Could I grab some assistance with these trades, please? I’m hoping to trade up atm, Rarity and demand wise, how is this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111463615&userid=262756&signature=YOkkc818qj8dFnWRk2VRjA

Also this item trade, please?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111463831&userid=262756&signature=UKr9JzCFcmVYQfdgePurDw


And also this trade too please!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111470847&userid=262756&signature=189gp6Ihs-F6B01YqYCDDg

Still looking for some assistance, please 🙏

[escarghost]

hi friends, item trade here! does this look fair, or at least fair enough? I know nothing about items lol trades/viewtrade.php?id=111480003&userid=285008&signature=mcPMesB0ltDnuC5O37m1SA