by 0000007 » Sat Oct 17, 2015 4:37 am
I do not support
I see how this could be neat or helpful trying to go through posts, but it would take a bit of coding and;
-if someone changes their username
personally, I'm changing my username all the time. or at least through a few different ones. but if someone changes their user wouldn't it link to the person who has taken that user? would you have to directly link the profile through the link regardless of the username at the time, than? it seems very confusing and wouldn't just be so simple as just linking the profile anymore.
+username symbols
what if a person cannot copy a username or retype it out due to having other symbols? it seems that quoting already solves this problem because it will copy it for them.
+ username spaces
unless there is a way to pull up a user profile and 'highlight' the whole name, how would this work for users with spaces in their name? that's more coding to add
-mobile notifications/notifications
where would this show up in our notifications? and what about mobile users? that's a whole new thing to code in and consider the layout of for both versions. I know mobile already cuts out some things- but it doesn't seem like this feature is something it would be able to just cut out
-quoting
its pretty much the same thing as quoting a post. I see how it could be helpful in keeping track of things, but isn't there a 'notify me when a reply is posted' button down at the bottom also used for that? (personally I don't use this but I'll try it out on this post to see how it works; I'm guessing it pms you saying another post was made on the thread). if you are talking directly to someone on a thread, its more simple to just quote the post. if you add this new feature, wouldn't it seem spam-ish to reply with a new post just talking directly to someone? you might as well pm them unless you're talking to multiple users. it makes it seem like a more private thing and would be harder to track what the person is replying to to see if it is off topic
sure, you get a notification, but if you're saying something that anyone can reply to than it'd be better to just read over the thread anyways just in case other people reply and don't link your user
ALSO, when someone replies to a thread after you have, the topic should be red again. so you can see when a person replies. its vague if they're replying to you or not but its a possibility that someone did since the last time you posted
---- if a quote would be too long to quote, or there are multiple, split them up and snip everything but the first sentance or so from them
its a good idea, but I just see it being somewhat unnecessary with the features we already have.