"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[Okapi-chan]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86326489&userid=726941&signature=skf0wJCRQQae6ZzRmqNZTQ
Is this fair? Thank you in advance!

[Flicka]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86286598&userid=9355&signature=Mxa4tyFijdtIqiNShz_4mg is this ok for my pon?

[Toxxic_22]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86327347&userid=970881&signature=Zh4lz2coaZ1ZkLkUtrShPQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86323771&userid=970881&signature=tyqeyiiiqyz7vpcD-MlqwA

Are these Fair? If not what needs to be added

[kanri;]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86326489&userid=726941&signature=skf0wJCRQQae6ZzRmqNZTQ
Is this fair? Thank you in advance!

it depends on how you see the demand. the clockwork bunny can go for a non (source) so it may be unfair to them, but it looks like a solid trade to me.

feel free to get a second opinion, as I may be off on that

[kököchin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86326489&userid=726941&signature=skf0wJCRQQae6ZzRmqNZTQ
Is this fair? Thank you in advance!

it depends on how you see the demand. the clockwork bunny can go for a non (source) so it may be unfair to them, but it looks like a solid trade to me.

feel free to get a second opinion, as I may be off on that

i agree~ in fact i would put further emphasis on the part that they'd be overpaying. the clockwork bun goes for a solid non & maybe even more w patience--however, i do not want to confirm that and have it be false. but a non is for sure. and w the fact that the clockwork bun is a store and cannot be rereleased, i'd take it in a heartbeat.

[kanri;]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86323156&userid=970881&signature=bM6Tq4m1Fk-VZ5rjCcszOA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86323771&userid=970881&signature=tyqeyiiiqyz7vpcD-MlqwA

Are these Fair? If not what needs to be added

not sure if you saw my response on this or you're just looking for a second opinion, but here was my assessment of the first trade:

can't speak for the second one because I'm pretty bad at items, but the first one looks unfair to the bottom. Added up, those pets come out roughly to 300 C$, give or take a little. The items aren't worth a jump of 700 C$ so I'd say it's major, major overpay on your part

[Toxxic_22]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86323156&userid=970881&signature=bM6Tq4m1Fk-VZ5rjCcszOA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86323771&userid=970881&signature=tyqeyiiiqyz7vpcD-MlqwA

Are these Fair? If not what needs to be added

not sure if you saw my response on this or you're just looking for a second opinion, but here was my assessment of the first trade:

can't speak for the second one because I'm pretty bad at items, but the first one looks unfair to the bottom. Added up, those pets come out roughly to 300 C$, give or take a little. The items aren't worth a jump of 700 C$ so I'd say it's major, major overpay on your part

Oh shoot! I meant to replace the one you answered on! I was gonna switch it out because I got another trade I need help with sorry about that!

[Hereisdan]

Any advise on this trade?


Would appreciate a second opinion on this trade as well?

[Okapi-chan]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86326489&userid=726941&signature=skf0wJCRQQae6ZzRmqNZTQ
Is this fair? Thank you in advance!

it depends on how you see the demand. the clockwork bunny can go for a non (source) so it may be unfair to them, but it looks like a solid trade to me.

feel free to get a second opinion, as I may be off on that

i agree~ in fact i would put further emphasis on the part that they'd be overpaying. the clockwork bun goes for a solid non & maybe even more w patience--however, i do not want to confirm that and have it be false. but a non is for sure. and w the fact that the clockwork bun is a store and cannot be rereleased, i'd take it in a heartbeat.

Thank you both! I offered a non instead but they preferred the first trade ^-^

[Skelita]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86323230&userid=911583&signature=aHX-i9LGA31maZGTvYfJyQ

I really need help with this trade :s would this be fair to my Lion? I value it at 2non but idk how much their pets are :s