The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[luca_balsa]

Another Opinion?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83277147&userid=821137&signature=S_RGb9dqiZBJNaGF2DO4DQ

[Trickz]

Winged Wood Angel + Angel Advent + Brown Collie = ??

List-wise, please! I'd love a rarity and demand answer if possible.


Could I get a second opinion?

[OneSmartChicken]

I'm very nervous so I've got two :'D
The item is mine

The collared cat is mine

[daybreak.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83275405&userid=947682&signature=RWUAEYHic62u6YwmbnVoBw
Is this fair?

According to the Rares List they're overpaying by quite a bit. The cat's a Tier 1 Advent, while the Grinner is a Tier 2 Sept. List. Still, it's up to you to decide which you like best. I've heard Grinners don't have the best demand, whilst sitting cats are very easy to trade off in my experience c:

Is this fair? Would the other person need to add? (My side is all the lions)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83276385&userid=138535&signature=VqF1x-PoE_8xV7aCnZikkQ

Since their Advent is only worth 3-4 Mixed '09 rares, according to the list, I'd say that's unfair to you. They'd still need to add something worth your '19 lion set and about 2-3 pets of your gryphon set, imo. This without considering demand c:

[honeycreeper]

I need some advice on this bid, what needs to be added? Thank you for any help!

xx

honey

[Horsesrule5000]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83273927&userid=613733&signature=cwiP1V2oHcNQSy8p7R_Oww
Fair? Thank you.

[daybreak.]

I'm very nervous so I've got two :'D
The item is mine

The item is from a 2010 set. Not sure if it's worth a rare or uncommon from that same year. Either way, I'd say their side's worth about a '12 rare, so they're technically a bit short but quantity has its own worth, imo c:

The collared cat is mine

Technically a fair swap, rarity wise c: I've heard from this trade that Scourge has a bit more demand, but that's really up to you and your trading partner

[IdolDream]

Seems kinda silly to ask, but honestly, these days with demand, I wouldn't know with this one. Any help would be super appreciated!

spotted tribal + purple toxic + Sunjewel = red rose dog + Red Cerb + White lolita?

[phxyvi]

Another Opinion?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83277147&userid=821137&signature=S_RGb9dqiZBJNaGF2DO4DQ

Imo this is very very unfair to you, those pets don’t add up to the zebra

[Sarin]

Is this a fair offer for the UR Aussie?