Signature Criticism! [v.1]

[lopez arguello]

AAHHAHA how do i critique this

ok so i think the font text is a bit too big, and i feel like the flower png is unnecassary [i cant english]

other than that, i love your sig

[Organ]

Those hands are scary but still good though


Please hate on my signature thanks

[ryuunosuke]

not sure if you're being serious, but okay.

the images are very very lossy. it's a .jpg, use .png images instead. also, use picresize to resize your images for a signature otherwise it will become pixelated and lossy. the quote 'get dunked on' appears a LOT in people's signatures, being a popular sans quote from UNDERTALE. the hearts should be replaced with something less bright, too. the text in the 'get dunked on' is also hard to read, but is well type-set. just some tweaks would really improve this signature!

EDIT: also, get artist permission for using their art in signatures. it's the respectful thing to do. do not just say 'credit to ____ on tumblr!'. make sure you get their permisson!!!

[BunsBunsBuns]

I love your sig, first of all;
I think it's really well done, and I love cluttered sigs honestly; but..
I found it really hard to follow the words(maybe it's just me)
and I like the giant photo, it makes me want to look over the
whole signature, but it's awkward because it is purposely blurry. cx
Either way, it's unique, and It's a 10/10

[sekuban]

the only thing I think is that the text looks a bit plain! otherwise amazing

[Aliria]

Overall it's a pretty good signature, there's not much to critique. It's a bit simple, and feels like there's something missing on the right. The flowery things on the top look a bit squished, if you could make them a bit wider they'd look better. The borders on the sides don't quite line up, the one with all the dots is a few pixels taller than the rectangles. It also might look a bit better if the rectangles were dark grey instead of black.

[BunsBunsBuns]

I really like your siggy, except for the buttons thing affecting the color scheme, but it isn't really that bad. It's a really cute sig!

[Organ]

Nothing wrong with it but here we go


I didn't really get the text 'I think I'm old enough to know where did everyone go'. You could add just a little bit more color.


That's all :3

[AtlasHyperion]

You've got a lot of empty boxes on the right, there's a box with just a ton of "BIO BIO BIO" and the thin tall borders are all the same.

[lopez arguello]

theres just a big "NO DIRECT LINKING" pic in the middle.