brightheart, most definitely. graystripe was constantly going through a war with himself for the majority of the first book arc. brightheart, on the other hand, even after she was attacked by dogs, the authors didn't force us to feel sympathy for her! she rebuilt her strength and confidence on her own, with help from cloudtail. we were forced to feel sorry for everything graystripe went through, and he's just a dislikable character overall. also, there is no way on earth the he should still be alive either, he's too old, even for a feral cat. i preferred graystripe when he was an apprentice. anyway, rant over, brightheart is much better.
tallstar or onestar?