I like the idea of re starting from the beginning
The thing is, i lost Luna's foal's form again, but good news is that i can re make it
Also, i kinda wanna re start since when new people join, everyone will have 33475487320987654321123456789 mares from the very start of the rp which can be a bit unfair o3o
Also, i bet some people will get rid of some mares and add new ones. Same with the stallions o3o
Like, for example, i'll change Romeo's appearance and have him all grown up as well as keeping Mark
And then i'd get rid of all of my mares except Gloria, Angel and Taehyung and add one or two more new mares :3
Also, there will be a lot of new mares roaming around and then stallions can simply go and approach them and then build up again
So i'll personally just stick with option 3
Also, some mares aren't active anymore in some stallion's herds and it will be really hard for people to move on with these mares that aren't active and when people will come back, they will get a bit confused on what's going on with the herd
So even if we start and have our old characters with their old herd, stallions will have minus a few mares