by Celozon » Wed May 15, 2019 9:33 am
The thread you mentioned that you found is probably still the best place to ask, simply because those who are more knowledgeable in this area will probably be following the thread and be able to help more. If you don't want to give an opinion yourself, you may consider looking through recent pages for people who seem to have a good idea on prices and PM them, or just look through for opinions on art that is similar in quality to your own.
I'll do my best to give my own opinion since I do stalk the art shop board a bit, in the future its good to give some examples of your own art, though in this case it was fairly easy to just look in your gallery. I will probably give excessive amounts of info you don't really need, sorry about that, you can skip down to the bolded bit if you don't want my blabber. And to be clear, this will just be my own opinion on my own limited experience in the art shops board, I usually have difficulty helping people price their art as well as in the end it is mostly up to the artist and how they value their art.
All said, I'd say what was offered would be fairly normal payment for a fullbody piece of your art quality. Though CS artists in my opinion tend to under-price themselves due to all the competition, and users not wanting to pay high prices. Considering how good your art is though you could probably charge higher prices and still get customers. What they've offered amounts to a couple 2009 very rares + several 2010 rares, but you should also consider how interested you are in the pets offered or their trading value to you. Unfortunately rats do tend to be harder to trade or trade for less, consider how it would effect you and whether it lowers the overall value of the offer for you or not.
As for actual pricing suggestion, I'm just gonna go by what I personally would charge if this were my own art. Assuming it is around the same quality as the oekaki's in your gallery, and takes approx an hour (or a bit more), I'd say for that payment, a half-body, or a simple full body. (partly based off my own normal price for pixel headshots which take me about an hour and I charge 2 2009 very rares for those)
But personally the easiest way I found to decide prices was find a general range I was comfortable charging at, then opening an art shop and adjusting depending on how many people wanted my art (raise the prices if there are a lot, lower if there aren't enough, basic stuff). That might not be something you want to do, but its what I found as the best way to find a median between not underpricing yourself but still getting customers.
You're not gonna please everyone with prices, if you charge higher (I consider myself in that range) some people will balk at the price/say its too high, but I personally don't feel its worth underpricing my own art, and I still get plenty of interest from people willing to pay. All said, charge what feels right for you, what you're willing to take for your time and energy, if they don't want to pay that much its their problem, not yours.