Is this trade fair?

[shiningsun10]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76494218&userid=749223&signature=ZUMdYnxSFAUD_U2DW-Sy8Q

[Aliria]

Questions like this belong in this thread.

I'd say the cat is overpay. Even though it isn't very rare, it's still a store pet, and a 2014 store pet is worth quite a bit more than a 2013 rare. (However, I'm pretty out of touch with trading these days, so getting a second opinion from the proper thread might be a good idea)