__Cerberus__ wrote:Kinda been getting annoyed with an argument in my family.
So I'll bring this up, and not saying my side till I hear others.
Would you have a pitbull around your family?
Are they a mean breed?
Nature or nurture?
In general I would be fine with a Pitbull around my family but it would depend on the individual dog, which is true of all breeds. Though of course it depends on you mean by around. I would not leave any dog of any breed alone with small children, it is not safe for either child or dog. And of course if anything does go wrong it will be the dog that gets blamed/punished for it.
No dog breed is "mean" dogs are domesticated animals which mean that humans as a species are responsible for all that is good and bad about them.
It is both nature and nurture. Some dogs (terriers are more likely but can happen with any breed) are genetically predisposed to dog aggression. Other breeds were bred to be protective of their family around strangers, chase/kill small animals or want to herd things. Most of the time with training and management these behaviors can be controlled.
On rare occasions dogs have been so poorly bred that they are almost uncontrollable, though this can happen with any dog breed. Pitbulls are largely BYB mixes, not APBTs, and there are a lot of them out there so you will likely see problems crop up in them more then a rarer breed. Also there is the problem of dog fighting and being favored by criminals which give them a bad reputation. Also the media is biased against Pitbulls, studies have been done proving as much.
Historically APBTs, because they were bred for fighting were also bred to be very people friendly so that people could actually reach into the middle of a dog fight and break it up without getting bit by either dog. Of course some (like every other dog breed) can be human aggressive due to a multitude of factors. And though Pitbulls have more incidents of dog aggression then other breeds such as Beagles, there are still plenty of Pitbulls that go their whole lives without showing dog aggression.
Pitbulls can be great family dogs though they are not for everyone. Anyone who tells you any breed of dog is right for everyone clearly does not know a lot about dogs. If anyone is considering one (or a dog of any breed) they should learn about the breed and decided if it's a good fit for their family, they should also consider the temperament of the individual dog they are considering as well. And of course you need to be prepared for the hate you're going to get when owning a Pitbull, and of course they are illegal in some places, not welcome in some doggie daycares, etc.