***Mods Please Lock: New Thread Up!***

[~IshikawaPrefecture~]

I agreed and I do believe that Deadfoot's Crowfeather's father

[Lil'Tiger]

I've never liked Tigerstar when I read the first book I didn't like him then when he set the trap for Bluestar and it hit Cinderpelt I disliked him even more. Now I like Crookedstar even more, too. I want a Super Edition about Spottedleaf.

No.
Not a SE about that mary sue.

[~IshikawaPrefecture~]

Well sorry but there will be no Spottedleaf Edition

At least some people like Tigerstar

[katniss,]

I've never liked Tigerstar when I read the first book I didn't like him then when he set the trap for Bluestar and it hit Cinderpelt I disliked him even more. Now I like Crookedstar even more, too. I want a Super Edition about Spottedleaf.

No.
Not a SE about that mary sue.

Tiger, why do you want a SE about Deadfoot?

I thik Spottedleaf is tooo perfect. Literally- she is beautiful, talented, smart, trustworthy, great medicine cat, gentle, and what not. -curses-

I hated Spotted+Fire. It made absolutely no sense to me. How could Firepaw love Spottedleaf, when she was older than him by a lot?

[~IshikawaPrefecture~]

I've never liked Tigerstar when I read the first book I didn't like him then when he set the trap for Bluestar and it hit Cinderpelt I disliked him even more. Now I like Crookedstar even more, too. I want a Super Edition about Spottedleaf.

No.
Not a SE about that mary sue.

Tiger, why do you want a SE about Deadfoot?

I thik Spottedleaf is tooo perfect. Literally- she is beautiful, talented, smart, trustworthy, great medicine cat, gentle, and what not. -curses-

I hated Spotted+Fire. It made absolutely no sense to me. How could Firepaw love Spottedleaf, when she was older than him by a lot?

lol yeah I mean a older she-cat loved by a younger tom

[Lil'Tiger]

There's so much we don't know about him. Besides, we don't even have a Windclan SE.
Here's why:
1. How did his foot go limp/be broken
2. How'd he die?
3. Was his real name actually Deadkit?
And loads more.

[- poppeh]

I don't really like Spotedleaf just she like died in the 1st book. But I was thinking like "Spottedleaf's Sacrifice". Or something. But a SE about Tallstar I think may be cool.

[katniss,]

There's so much we don't know about him. Besides, we don't even have a Windclan SE.
Here's why:
1. How did his foot go limp/be broken
2. How'd he die?
3. Was his real name actually Deadkit?
And loads more.

But he isn't a main character, so to say, while all the other special editions are.
We dont have a Shadowclan cat either. Well, I guess YS could count, even though she was Shadow/Thunder.

[~IshikawaPrefecture~]

Yeah maybe all that stuff when people would want a SE about Deadfoot or Tallstar

[Lil'Tiger]

Crookedstar wasn't much of one either, and he has an SE.