rhythm wrote:brigitte is supposed to be a healer/tank hybrid, but having to do damage to do any substantial amount of healing makes her feel torn between all three roles—and because of that, she can’t be particularly good at healing, tanking, or dps without being op. i wish they’d lessen the need to do damage—like maybe blocking damage with her shield should activate her passive healing instead. that would encourage shield usage, and make her more of an actual healer/tank hybrid imo. the size of her shield would need to be made a little bigger to make that viable, but.... i don’t know. i agree that she’s just kinda odd as she is now, but at the same time she hasn’t been out for very long, so i’m willing to wait a little longer for people to figure out where she fits in best.
This is exactly my issue with her. I used to think
Moira was too focused on DPS, then they added Brigitte and... Yikes. I don't know why we need so many healers that seem to do a better job as DPS than healers. Plus, with her armor and HP she's ridiculously tanky for a support/a hero of her size- but she doesn't often tank in a way that's actually beneficial to her team, only in a way that's beneficial to her. It feels way too difficult to 1v1 her- if I'm playing DPS and I get the drop on a support hero, they shouldn't be
that good at defending themselves with zero help from their team, unless they're a seriously skilled player. The point of support is to help their team, and be more reliant on their team in exchange. Brigitte doesn't do that.
I still think Brigitte should have been a tank. A tank/healer hybrid that's a real, competent tank with some healing abilities on the side would be better than this mess.
And on top of that, she's just plain annoying to fight. The stun, the knockback, her range and hitboxes make any sense, and her primary fire knocks you around all the time- it feels like this game is getting saturated with abilities that are more frustrating to the enemies than they are useful to you. There are certain heroes and certain abilities that I don't really mind being killed by. Sure, I'd rather
not be dead, but I either shrug it off or credit the other player's skill, then wait for respawn. But abilities like Brigitte's make it harder to fight back by stunning you and knocking you around, and they aren't particularly difficult abilities to even land. So dying to her just feels annoying and a bit cheap.