by polerberr » Thu Sep 06, 2012 3:10 am
@Haldir, sure join in ^^
Got to love the rock and pool song! XD
Darkstar you said "Smeagol says he "always helps" and "won't hurt a fly". But he tries to murder Sam and lure Frodo to Shelob's lair. And he bites off Frodo's finger. And he killed Deagol. For a ring." (pardon me for being too lazy to quote XD)
Well, Smeagol says he always helps and won't hurt a fly, but Gollum tries to murder Sam, bites off Frodo's finger, kills Deagol etc.
The ring corrupted Smeagol and created Gollum, but Frodo somehow manages to bring back Smeagol inside of him. I think it starts when Bilbo has the riddle game with Gollum, which brought back memories of his past life, and when Frodo calls him Smeagol for the first time in many years is what really did it.