The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Law]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=13664139&userid=18500&signature=N6CugHNiPox6I4oEu3OjUQ
if it's unfair, what could be added to make it fair?
the newborn is the xpps and the green swirl second stage has the yin-yang neclace

There's nothing on the top, but the pets on the bottom are worth a coontail... I think.

ah sorry it was for a moonswirl, what would need to be added?

Probably another non-coon/nontag/nonswirl. You'd need an expert's opinion on this though. >.<

Yellow sorbet
for
Joker?


PLEASE answer fast, the person is waiting!

Unfair to yellow sorbet in terms of rarity, but I think the joker wins out in terms of demand.

[tawnypelt3]

Uff. I have no idea. Considering the low demand of any fish, and the subsequent low-balling of value, is this near fair? I imagine rather (or really) unfair to them, but I have no idea what to add or what would be fair in terms of rares and/or uncommons. Help, please?

[gothcomplex]

Hello (:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EES1715t7g
could you tell me if this trade is fair, please? (:
Thank you~

[bodie]

Yellow sorbet
for
Joker?


PLEASE answer fast, the person is waiting!

Unfair to yellow sorbet in terms of rarity, but I think the joker wins out in terms of demand.

Thanks, any other opinions?

[Law]

Hello (:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EES1715t7g
could you tell me if this trade is fair, please? (:
Thank you~

Someone must really like the yingyang dog, because it looks like they are overpaying xD

[DistantFootsteps]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... I4oEu3OjUQ for moonswirl
if it's unfair, what could be added to make it fair?
the newborn is the xpps and the green swirl second stage has the yin-yang neclace

Probably another non-coon/nontag/nonswirl. You'd need an expert's opinion on this though. >.<

ok thankyou, any other opinions?

[gothcomplex]

Thanks (:
Would should they remove to make it more fair? c:

[sun+wfan]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ioGJXEizCw

[Lady Lesednik]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YEqg_k94vQ fair?

[dwarjam]

Is this fair?...