The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[GrotesqueNightmare]

Hey, nice people out there!

Someone wanted to get this cat from last year and told me she wanted to overpay. We edited quite a time, and now we are here: Could you please vote or tell me if this is an overpay or not? (it is no auction)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... yMfinSRzPA

Slightly overpaying, take out one pet from their side.

[Mythicwave]

Is this a fair trade? I know what the rares list says about the Pink Sorbet and the CE galaxy. But does the other pets fill the gap between them? If not, then what needs to be added?

[lilly1292269]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _qc7erjDQg
Is this fair? I really want that dog, but they want all of my rares, and Very rares from me. Please answer asap.

[Addict_with_a_pen]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=13506849&userid=130793&signature=XjpQrcIS_I40Do_Vu-KR8g

Fairr.? The rat is a very rare july 2008 re-release.C:

I think its unfair to you, personally... But I really dont know what the rat is worth. From just my experience with the other rats of that date, the lowest I have seen them worth are a low September. They are offering the equivalent of two mid advents...But you should get another opinion.[/quote]


Okaayy thanks, do you have any idea whati should add to make it fair..?

[GrotesqueNightmare]

Is this a fair trade? I know what the rares list says about the Pink Sorbet and the CE galaxy. But does the other pets fill the gap between them? If not, then what needs to be added?

I feel the 08 Halloween Dog fills in the gap nicely, I say this is fair.

[Klea]

Fair??? Thanks in advance
Fair?

Looking for a good answer

[Mythicwave]

Is this a fair trade? I know what the rares list says about the Pink Sorbet and the CE galaxy. But does the other pets fill the gap between them? If not, then what needs to be added?

I feel the 08 Halloween Dog fills in the gap nicely, I say this is fair.

Thank you. ^^

[lilly1292269]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=13508287&userid=265878&signature=1mgOx-nLe0_b_qc7erjDQg
Is this fair? I really want that dog, but they want all of my rares, and Very rares from me. Please answer asap.

[GrotesqueNightmare]

Fair??? Thanks in advance
Fair?

Looking for a good answer

This is very difficult b/c the cucumber just came out therefore in high demand making it's value skyrocket. It's really up to you.

[Liv.]

Is this fair? Its for a Spotted Tribal + 60 Chicken Dollars.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5GHKNwQH6Q
Any help is really appreciated, this is my dreamie so I don't want to make any rash decisions.