New Thread please lock <3

[Elettra]

Fair? I wasn't quite sure.... O__o

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vWp__MqanA

[Forever Lost]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=10770699&userid=192057&signature=p9zwl8OYQTY8hD4-vKWraQ I'm not good with item values...

I've heard 5 CS = a 2010 uncommon (Probably mid or late) so I think the wings, hair, and dress would fill the gap (though I'm not sure about the worth of those.)
I don't know about the others either, but I'm pretty sure that the robe is at least somewhat popular, and is worth more than a 2011 common alone.
You'll want another opinion, but with that I'm thinking it's unfair to you.

Thanks. Anyone else?

[Mythicwave]

Looking at the trade again:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Zhh3ggHNow

I don't see any other pets on their side on my wishlist to add. I think the dog is the only one I have, though I haven't checked. It would be between the owl or the horse that I could offer.

As I've said before, I value store pets at an 09 rare. So I'd say the owl would be the best to offer as fair as being fairness goes. Even though the horse is close in months to a regular December 09 rare (I'm pretty sure there's monthly releases as well as advents in December, as that's what happened in 2010), it only turned rare a few months ago.
Also as I said, I might be over or under valuing store pets, so you'll want another opinion.

[ButterflyChaser]

Looking at the trade again:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Zhh3ggHNow

I don't see any other pets on their side on my wishlist to add. I think the dog is the only one I have, though I haven't checked. It would be between the owl or the horse that I could offer.

As I've said before, I value store pets at an 09 rare. So I'd say the owl would be the best to offer as fair as being fairness goes. Even though the horse is close in months to a regular December 09 rare (I'm pretty sure there's monthly releases as well as advents in December, as that's what happened in 2010), it only turned rare a few months ago.
Also as I said, I might be over or under valuing store pets, so you'll want another opinion.

Thanks. I'll see if they are willing to wait a day or two.

[Its_Katt]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... yfxcaCHzDA

is that fair?

[Hekomi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=10770994&userid=215035&signature=TtNKflINrco-yfxcaCHzDA

is that fair?

Unfair to you.
-Komi

[Kellygreen16]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Qd5ZB330Uw

is this faire

[Fizzlebee]

This + This for my Red Rose Dog? Thanks! C:

It's unfair to you.
I don't really know what they'd need to add (since I don't think they reach Light Leopard level), but once they do reach light leopard level, they'll need to add something worth a Snowflake Bwolf at the least to get to a grinner, and they'll need to add a few mid advents to be fair for a Rose dog.
So you're going to have to get another opinion, but I'm going to say a lot.

Thanks, I appreciate it! Looking for another opinion.

[xo.coyote]

fair? :3
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4GLEWwo42g

[Hekomi]

fair? :3
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4GLEWwo42g

Unfair to the bottom.
-komi