New Thread please lock <3

[Mythicwave]

I'm not interested in the cotten candy rats, or the fish, and I'd rather trade the blue staff litter for other 2010's. Knowing that I'm going to remove at least the cotten candy rats, any idea what they'd need to add for it to be fair for 4 of them? (The cats, the peacock adult dog, and the dog next to it.) Or would the fish itself be fair for those four? <-- This one is a bit more pressing to me right now.

And are either one of these fair for my grinner? Also, which one of these is the better one?
That was all the rares they had. That was probably why they canceled. Still, would I have over or underpaid if they accepted?
This one I'm more interested in, but is it fair? Or, at least, fairer than the other one?

[Sme]

#1
#2
#3

I think #3 is the most fair. What do you think?

[Mythicwave]

#1
#2
#3

I think #3 is the most fair. What do you think?

Yeah, #3 is the best for you. I believe they're overpaying. The other two...I'd say those two are unfair to you, but get another opinion on that.

[Sagaline]

I would like some help with an auction bid:
How fair is this?
Any help appreciated

I think thats pretty unfair to, cake dogs go for white a lot usually

Agreed, it's very unfair to the Cake Dog.

Thanks for the help
(I'd completely forgotten I'd posted here XD)

[Solloby]

^ I agree with Mysticwave that 3 may be slightly unfair to them.

Can anyone help me with this, I can't add up pet values to save my life:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... y3d_2FkrJQ

[tigerwish~]

They are happy with this trade as I am too, but before they accept I wanted to know if it is fair or not. Thank you in advance.

[yumekari]

Would this be fair without the items? If not, what should be added/removed? Thanks!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZXA3pxSRVA

[Sme]

Thank you for your help c:

[♛ feral]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=10318616

Is this a good trade?

[Mythicwave]

I'm not interested in the cotten candy rats, or the fish, and I'd rather trade the blue staff litter for other 2010's. Knowing that I'm going to remove at least the cotten candy rats, any idea what they'd need to add for it to be fair for 4 of them? (The cats, the peacock adult dog, and the dog next to it.) Or would the fish itself be fair for those four? <-- This one is a bit more pressing to me right now. A general opinion would be nice, if you have some idea.

And are either one of these fair for my grinner? Also, which one of these is the better one?
That was all the rares they had. That was probably why they canceled. Still, would I have over or underpaid if they accepted?
This one I'm more interested in, but is it fair? Or, at least, fairer than the other one?