New thread, please lock.

[Coleslaw]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=10179400&userid=83916&signature=8P27gJebFpFxToqAnrZyFQ

Sent with "Please feel free to edit~ Thanks! ^^ ~Sorrel"
Cancelled with
"Please read my trade rules, and this is a pretty big underpay in the first place."

1. I don't see where I broke a rule. The only rule that would come close would be "Just because the pet is on my WL doesn't mean I'll pay anything for it". But I don't see where that comes in.
2. The Snowflake advent is the lowest valued advent. The rare cat I offered has been rare for a while, and it's only 1 month apart from the advent. The only thing would be that "dogs are more popular then cats" and I add other pets from their wishlist to account for that. B|

And even so, they could've easily edited. Instead they just cancelled.
~Sorrel

I dont trade 08s for 09s no matter what so maybe they wont either, i would have thought thats was unfair if it was me

So you're saying you wouldn't take a Wood Angel for a snowflake advent, no matter what? It's sad that people don't believe that 09s can be worth something too -.-;

~Sorrel

[Nikeapker=]]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=10179400&userid=83916&signature=8P27gJebFpFxToqAnrZyFQ

Sent with "Please feel free to edit~ Thanks! ^^ ~Sorrel"
Cancelled with
"Please read my trade rules, and this is a pretty big underpay in the first place."

1. I don't see where I broke a rule. The only rule that would come close would be "Just because the pet is on my WL doesn't mean I'll pay anything for it". But I don't see where that comes in.
2. The Snowflake advent is the lowest valued advent. The rare cat I offered has been rare for a while, and it's only 1 month apart from the advent. The only thing would be that "dogs are more popular then cats" and I add other pets from their wishlist to account for that. B|

And even so, they could've easily edited. Instead they just cancelled.
~Sorrel

I dont trade 08s for 09s no matter what so maybe they wont either, i would have thought thats was unfair if it was me

So you're saying you wouldn't take a Wood Angel for a snowflake advent, no matter what? It's sad that people don't believe that 09s can be worth something too -.-;

~Sorrel

well most of them dont equal 08s and i dont like that dog so i wouldnt but other people probably would

[Kaliyana]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=10179400&userid=83916&signature=8P27gJebFpFxToqAnrZyFQ

Sent with "Please feel free to edit~ Thanks! ^^ ~Sorrel"
Cancelled with
"Please read my trade rules, and this is a pretty big underpay in the first place."

1. I don't see where I broke a rule. The only rule that would come close would be "Just because the pet is on my WL doesn't mean I'll pay anything for it". But I don't see where that comes in.
2. The Snowflake advent is the lowest valued advent. The rare cat I offered has been rare for a while, and it's only 1 month apart from the advent. The only thing would be that "dogs are more popular then cats" and I add other pets from their wishlist to account for that. B|

And even so, they could've easily edited. Instead they just cancelled.
~Sorrel

I dont trade 08s for 09s no matter what so maybe they wont either, i would have thought thats was unfair if it was me

So you're saying you wouldn't take a Wood Angel for a snowflake advent, no matter what? It's sad that people don't believe that 09s can be worth something too -.-;

~Sorrel

I have to agree here. I'm getting sick of people telling me my '09 rares are worth nothing. Even worse when people say my Malk Cats aren't worth that much since dogs are valued more.
I'm sorry, but I get at least five trades a day from people asking for my Malk Cats; the demand for those is going up--they're OBVIOUSLY worth something is so many people want them.

And it really depends on how much you value the '09; if someone offered me a couple '09s that I really liked for a '08 that I really hated; I'd take it. I'd rather have the one I really like than the one I don't...
But I wouldn't take the Wood Winged for anything; I does not like it. ;P

And WHAT is with all the people in the FTT just posting "Agreed"? >.> It's annoying the crap out of me...
It doesn't matter what the other people say; the same users are saying "Agreed" and offering no other such comment. >.<
I bet they could agree to the trade being fair, but the minute someone who actually knows what they're talking about posts and says it's unfair they would say they agree to that to. *Grumbles*

[Sen507]

No, sometimes when people write "agreed" they are just backing up another person's statement since you do not want to base the fairness of a trade off of only one person's opinion.

[Kaliyana]

No, sometimes when people write "agreed" they are just backing up another person's statement since you do not want to base the fairness of a trade off of only one person's opinion.

Yes but that's ALL the do.
There's one user I've seen there and that's the ONLY thing they've said on the thread; is agreed. Nothing more.
And they're saying it to the questions that have already had multiple answers... Like three or four answers.
It just annoys me.

[Coleslaw]

I dont trade 08s for 09s no matter what so maybe they wont either, i would have thought thats was unfair if it was me

So you're saying you wouldn't take a Wood Angel for a snowflake advent, no matter what? It's sad that people don't believe that 09s can be worth something too -.-;

~Sorrel

I have to agree here. I'm getting sick of people telling me my '09 rares are worth nothing. Even worse when people say my Malk Cats aren't worth that much since dogs are valued more.
I'm sorry, but I get at least five trades a day from people asking for my Malk Cats; the demand for those is going up--they're OBVIOUSLY worth something is so many people want them.

And it really depends on how much you value the '09; if someone offered me a couple '09s that I really liked for a '08 that I really hated; I'd take it. I'd rather have the one I really like than the one I don't...
But I wouldn't take the Wood Winged for anything; I does not like it. ;P

And WHAT is with all the people in the FTT just posting "Agreed"? >.> It's annoying the crap out of me...
It doesn't matter what the other people say; the same users are saying "Agreed" and offering no other such comment. >.<
I bet they could agree to the trade being fair, but the minute someone who actually knows what they're talking about posts and says it's unfair they would say they agree to that to. *Grumbles*

--you wouldn't take the woodwing for just a medieval pet? It's good fodder, since quite alot of people including me love it ;P

On FTT thing;

Agreed

8D
lol, jk.
Though I agree, that would probably be the outcome most of the time. It's annoying and pointless, and if you're just going to say agreed, get off the FTT. We have other people who ADD to that "agreed" and give explanation.

~Sorrel

[Sen507]

If the explanation has already been given properly why explain it yet again? People don't just write agreed (at least none that I've seen) but it's a common response when there is already a reply or two and you just want to seal the deal on whether the trade is fair or not.

[Kaliyana]

If the explanation has already been given properly why explain it yet again? People don't just write agreed (at least none that I've seen) but it's a common response when there is already a reply or two and you just want to seal the deal on whether the trade is fair or not.

Go look at the last couple pages; agreed is actually said quiet a lot.
But I'm not ranting about them saying they agree; I'm ranting about how it's only the same few users who post "agreed" and nothing else. In my opinion just saying agreed is spam. I hate it. It annoys me. I want to smack people in the face with a rubber chicken when they continuously say that and nothing else...

@Shutter Shades--> Nope; wouldn't take it. Because with my luck, once I got it; I wouldn't be able to trade it off for anything I actually want. That's happened a couple times; I get a good pet for trade fodder, and then people offer me nothing but my hoard pets and anyone I send a trade to offering that pet doesn't want it. (My UR Apple for example...)

[Speedythecat]

When i said i would trade rares for bulk amount of cat hoard pets this is NOT what i meant!

[Kaliyana]

To prove my above point about only being offered hoard pets for my apple:
No message, ready to accept, user is from November 2010. ;-;
Offered me the Rainbow Mane Bunny (hoard) to get around the wishlist lock. ;-;
Neither of those store pets are on my wishlist. *Sighs*

This user even has TONS of good rares ('08s) and a Rose Dog. >.> They could have at LEAST offered those instead of the freaking store pets. >.<
I think it was a failed ninja attempt...