New Thread please lock <3

[koth]

is this fair? if it isn't how can it be made fair?

I think it's unfair to you, they need more rares from '09 and less from '10 and '11.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=9872737&userid=2595&signature=a_cpl1anSghkNFZJBJS2AQ

Would this be fair? If not, would anyone have an idea of what to add to make it fair for me???
Any replies would be greatly appreciated, thanks <3

It's unfair to the line tribal by quite a bit. They would need to add more septembers and maybe one august '08

[Thuban]

Ok guys this one is probably tough (as there are 93 pets on my side).

Decided to go all out and try to get myself a yellow toxic with whatever pets i had... I still dont think I have hit the point of fair but how close would this put me?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JXvhcwRhTg

[wit]

Ok guys this one is probably tough (as there are 93 pets on my side).

Decided to go all out and try to get myself a yellow toxic with whatever pets i had... I still dont think I have hit the point of fair but how close would this put me?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JXvhcwRhTg

Really unfair to Yellow Toxic

[koth]

Ok guys this one is probably tough (as there are 93 pets on my side).

Decided to go all out and try to get myself a yellow toxic with whatever pets i had... I still dont think I have hit the point of fair but how close would this put me?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JXvhcwRhTg

You're still quite far, you would need to add september '08s, and maybe one common august '08

[charliexx]

Ok guys this one is probably tough (as there are 93 pets on my side).

Decided to go all out and try to get myself a yellow toxic with whatever pets i had... I still dont think I have hit the point of fair but how close would this put me?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JXvhcwRhTg

about.. .fair

[PitchBlack]

is this fair? if it isn't how can it be made fair?

I think it's unfair to you, they need more rares from '09 and less from '10 and '11.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=9872737&userid=2595&signature=a_cpl1anSghkNFZJBJS2AQ

Would this be fair? If not, would anyone have an idea of what to add to make it fair for me???
Any replies would be greatly appreciated, thanks <3

It's unfair to the line tribal by quite a bit. They would need to add more septembers and maybe one august '08

Big thanks to all three of you for the quick responses, I will forward this to the other person and see what they can come up with ^^

[devimon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=9883867&userid=154000&signature=_wf2dYsKXYGjpdqit7Ka_Q
any help? took a ton to get my pup. thanks a ton to the answerer!

Looks about fair to me. You may need a second opinion though.

I say it's either fair or unfair to them

I'm sorry but that's not an answer
"It's fair..or not" the point of the thread is to be told one or the other, of course it's either fair or unfair, please only answer if you actually know, it's actually quite upsetting how much "I think it's this" "I don't know really but I think this"
If you don't know then don't answer and confuse people please.

[ericarawrr]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... VnhIwyLn2g

I still feel this is unfair. i dont have much value to rats, ponies, or rabbits.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... CqsjWFtQtA

Hows this one?

[Thuban]

Ok guys this one is probably tough (as there are 93 pets on my side).

Decided to go all out and try to get myself a yellow toxic with whatever pets i had... I still dont think I have hit the point of fair but how close would this put me?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JXvhcwRhTg

You're still quite far, you would need to add september '08s, and maybe one common august '08

cant do that when you dont have them I have very very few 08s (and of those, most of them are pound pets). I'm actually not all that fond of toxics in general, but the green one i got from the pound (and the nick green toxic) are rather pitiful sitting around all by themselves. This person has 25 pages worth of wishlist to go on, and i'm sure that even if i added every single pet (including the duplicates) I probably still wouldnt get close. Me, I appreciate the effort at least when people do things like this to me, and i am mainly curious about how far a person would have to go when they dont have 08s to work with.

Thanks guys.

[wit]

I'm sorry but that's not an answer
"It's fair..or not" the point of the thread is to be told one or the other, of course it's either fair or unfair, please only answer if you actually know, it's actually quite upsetting how much "I think it's this" "I don't know really but I think this"
If you don't know then don't answer and confuse people please.

You obviously didn't read it properly.

It's either fair to the top or unfair to the top pet not the trade itself, your anger is not needed. But Yes, yes it is an answer