New Thread please lock <3

[Centri]

This?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Jlr99Ao3iQ

[.muse.]

This?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Jlr99Ao3iQ

That is either fair or slight overpay for the joker. With the Yellow Tox being very close to it in rarity the other rares are hard to tell if they make the difference or overshoot it. Specially with that 08 Rat since I'm not good judging rat involved trades at all.

[A i]

Iis fair for thr joker and if not there over paying for the joker

No, that is unfair to the joker. The store pets and items don't add up to over 100 C$, the Joker is worth roughly 700$ So the store pets and items are maybe 1/7th the worth. Without something on the main of the Rares list I wouldn't accept that for a joker.

Is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4hG3MUYtPw
Thanks ^^

Unfair to Cake dog.

No unfair to the September pet. The cake dog isn't even on the rares list while the September is.

the cake dog actually is on the list.. :3

The September '08 List
(note that there is a gap in worth between these pets and the July/Augusts)
Dark Leopard = Orange Cerberus = Black Advent
Grey Dragon = Devil/Blood PPS
Blue Rose = Red-X = Angel Advent
Purple Batdog
Cake Dogs = White Dragon

[smoothiemaster772]

Alright thanks c: Then what about this?

[.muse.]

AI, that is not the nick Cake Dog. That is linked, if you clicked it, to the September Birthday cake Dogs.

[Solloby]

Ai: That refers to the September cake dogs, the Nick cake dog was released later. That said, isn't the Nick Cake dog worth a common September? I can't double check because someone deleted one of the resources I use for references, hopefully it'll be recovered soon.

Centri: The Easter dogs aren't worth anything in the trade because the other pets are so much more valuable, but the advent rat, soxic/sortic and gryphon are good. I'd say it might be fair, but it's definitely not overpay; Joker is very hard to get a hold of.

Smoothiemaster772: Technically unfair to Gearback, but people pay outrageously for Jokers sometimes, so it's your call. Gearback is also fairly popular I think. Maybe get an opinion from someone that's traded Jokers before.

What do I need to remove to make this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... KYfnS2qSnQ

[.muse.]

Alright thanks c: Then what about this?

Ninja'd. but I agree that this is overpay to the Joker.

[A i]

ah is that so, my bad my bad..i was told every cake dog worth the same, luckily i haven't traded for one yet o.o

[Centri]

Ok, thanks!

[Shalyon]

Is this fair?
I think that without the rare easter pps is more fair, but I'm not sure

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... C0Ln6blR5Q