New Thread please lock <3

[iHeartOnHoliday]

Is this fair?
Thank you so very much!

[yumekari]

Is this a fair trade? If not, what should be added/removed?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dDYZP2L_xQ

It's very unfair to you so add more rares to your side

Thanks x3 You mean their side, right? How much?

[Catfight]

Purple UR Tess Mint Horse + ? = Green UR Tess Mint Horse?

[Briony]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Hx_ydA2l6Q


fair???

[wifi]

Is a V-day Malk PPS (Feb. '09 VR) worth a Green Liontail ('09 VR Store Pet, also avalible in early '10)?
If not, which side is it unfair to, and what should be added to the underpaying side?
Thank you :]

[xNocturnalKittenX]

Hello. ^^; I'm pretty sure this is unfair. Can anyone tell me what should be changed?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=9796805&userid=17303&signature=icd_GsQNTvAGZuDDLcqNdQ
Thanks in advance. =)

[azalea]

IS this fair ?

The Red X is worth more than the Red Rose, but there's a BMD which is pretty equal to a Red Rose to help balance that out. However it's unfair to them because of the other advent. The horse is VR because it's a store pet, although it's worth more than most store pets I'd only estimate its worth to be an 09 rare and a few uncommons at the most. The advent is much more than that C: So I say unfair to them ^^

However if you remove the advent and just leave the burnt dog, the red rose, and the BMD it would be unfair to the horse, I believe. Best thing to do here is remove the advent and replace it with something of less value like an 09 rare dog and maybe a few uncommons from that year as well~ C:

Is this trade fair? Thanks in advance

No, not to me. I heard the old store pets were worth a 2009 pet so these very rares must just be a 2008 rare or something. But PLEASE get a second opinion because I have a strong filling i'm probably wrong.

...

Ok, then any second opinion?

Both of the store pets are only worth a few 09 uncommons, a rare at the most. The store horse because it's a VR and the dog because it's quite popular. I'm not strong on quantity trades but I'd say that it's slightly unfair to the store pets. Your side has lots and lots of uncommons, but they aren't uncommons that are worth especially much? |D I'd remove alot of the '11 uncommons and replace them with 4-5 '10 uncommon dogs instead C:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=9793151&userid=21109&signature=VVCUm4OXHRrFPILea2834Q

Fair?

Looks unfair to them to me D: Get a second opinion though, I'm not sure the worth of the April Fool's Cat these days C:

hi! this fair? thanks.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ct95eUfKaA

hmm its about fair

thanks. any others? i am a bit aprehensive on this, considering the fact that those Easter rares are usually worth 2010 uncommons.

I think its unfair to you. Easter was just a couple months ago, and as you said they aren't worth that much. A griffon store dog is worth a few 09 uncommons, possibly even an 09 rare to some people. They should add an early to mid 09 uncommon and then it will be more fair IMO C:

Is this a fair trade? If not, what should be added/removed?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dDYZP2L_xQ

It's unfair to you I believe, but I'm not sure enough on the worth of the rat to tell you what should be added. I'll get back to you on that C:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ysTK6FRYZg

Is this fair?

Unfair, just 2 or 3 of the pets on their side should be enough for the fox. The foxes were a more common uncommon xD

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=9809504&userid=34313&signature=0umgq1lvMv-rtXwn7KdPTA
though it's 2008, i'm not sure of tess horse's rarity C:

The horse is about worth an early 09 rare, if I'm not mistaken that Malk dog is from early 09 as well, so I'd say fair ouo b

Is this fair?
Thank you so very much!

I'd say unfair to them.
UR apple is worth a UR horse, its just below rarity of a blue balloon, and what you're offering is lots of more recent rares that aren't worth as much. The septembers are a good place to start, but you still need more of those and more high rarity ones ouo b


/dead ; n ;

[Rosa.Wolke]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4Ug8GygCEA
Someone wants the black dragon for a dream thread, but I heard they were worth more than the other dragon dogs.

[BPeppers]

Is this fair? owo I'm hesitant to give up the grapes.

[Ciriun]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UKXU5SrMug

Hey everyone, just wanted to run another trade by the experts before accepting.