New Thread please lock <3

[kivr & fireflii]

I need help, is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aTl6H1XDJQ

Unfair to them

[Sebeon]

I need help, is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aTl6H1XDJQ

I would say unfair to Green DD and Burnt Dog. The cats were pretty common.
Get another opinion, though.

[lucifer morningstar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0aZF9lgOVw

Fair for the VR purple bat dog from Halloween of '08?

[.NAZE.]

Is one of these fellows :

fair for the recent Elven Set?

Danke.

[lucifer morningstar]

Is one of these fellows :

fair for the recent Elven Set?

Danke.

Personally, I'd say no. A set of 2011 items for an early '09 rare? But that's just me talking. Get 2nd opinions!

[Candied Snow]

Is one of these fellows :

fair for the recent Elven Set?

Danke.

Personally, I'd say no. A set of 2011 items for an early '09 rare? But that's just me talking. Get 2nd opinions!

Agreed I don't think the elven items are worth that much.

[Hideś]

Is Target Dog fair for any of these bunnies?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3cE5Fvj4cA

[.NAZE.]

Is one of these fellows :

fair for the recent Elven Set?

Danke.

Personally, I'd say no. A set of 2011 items for an early '09 rare? But that's just me talking. Get 2nd opinions!

[color=#BF0040][size=85][center] 'Twas what I was thinking as well, I mean, just.. An early '09 for almost anything from '11?
I mean.. Just.. Whut.
Anywho, thanks for the input Stonestable and Ani. /brobump.

[azalea]

Is this fair?
If unfair, what needs to be changed?

Last I'd heard, wasn't the Kiss PPS worth a common September? If so, very unfair to you. If not, I'm not sure...

Kiss PPS is from August 2009. ^^ I think it's unfair to them, maybe add just a few early/mid 09 rares?

It depends on the opinion of each person, I think ^^

Rarity wise it's probably more like an advent (one of the less common ones) but it's one of the more popular pps dogs on CS, so you could definitely find a few people that would pay a common september for it ouo

In cases like that, I usually value it in the median, so to me it's worth a common late october or november 08 ^^
If you use that mid value, in my opinion, it's a bit unfair to the BW~ ouo~ It's a difference that could either be negligible or big enough to be unfair depending on what the burnt dog rarity comes out to, if that makes sense at all |D It's hard to tell if that trade is fair, especially since the burnt dogs have no rarity yet (although they are high in demand right now so that's something to consider too actually), and the KISS pps's value is very debatable (again because of demand issues) ; so really that trade could go either way |D

///completely unhelpful~~~~ OTL

I'd put more pets on the KISS's side, simply because I personally the burnt dogs are going to be a "rare uncommon" rather than an "uncommon rare", that plus my "median" value for the KISS is a bit more than the advent~ C:

Not totally sure, so correct me if I'm wrong |D

Is one of these fellows :

fair for the recent Elven Set?

Danke.

Nope~ Elven sets are about worth 2-3 09 uncommons or a recent rare C:

Is Target Dog fair for any of these bunnies?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3cE5Fvj4cA

Together all those bunnies are fair I think~ ouo...That's a very tentative answer |D
The last two are worth 2 common 08 advents or 1 rarer advent, the first one is worth 1 common 08 advent, if you bundled them all together it should/might be fair IMO |D
Get a second opinion though, I'm not strong on bunny rarities ;3;

[Hideś]

Is Target Dog fair for any of these bunnies?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3cE5Fvj4cA

[/center]
Together all those bunnies are fair I think~ ouo...That's a very tentative answer |D
The last two are worth 2 common 08 advents or 1 rarer advent, the first one is worth 1 common 08 advent, if you bundled them all together it should/might be fair IMO |D
Get a second opinion though, I'm not strong on bunny rarities ;3;

Thanks^^
Second opinion?