The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[saturnalia]

Help with this please?

[fawn ⚢]

Hi, anyone more knowledgeable on the new rarity system than me and could help me with these two trades?
this one and this one, thank you so much!

[chongyun]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111296992&userid=888783&signature=vxtUnnfSdxzKS_CPwOKw9A


any help is greatly appreciated!

[R a i n b o w]

Ellloooo i wanted to ask if this Is fair? thank youu

[charliethebugfan]

Hi guys! Would this trade
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111286898&userid=1080350&signature=R1FNgL2oj3waoYUQDa2R-Q
be fair? I'm hoarding horses so I'm asking date + rarity wise! Thanks in advance! ^^

bump :33

Definitely unfair to you, if you value 1VUC=2UC=4C. They don’t have enough quantity on their side to add up to your pets. I ignored dates for the purposes of this trade, since it’s pretty balanced overall, other than your second ‘15VUC.

thank you!

[GhostPants]

how does this look <3?

[EchothroughDarkness]

Can you help? Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111283390&userid=410864&signature=xjFLu0sumb8Lrd53ZZhHBw

[BillyBoi]

Hey guys I have two bids that I’m not 100% sure the value on, I know the first one will be a lil over 1.5Nons from the UR but I just want to know which one would be the better bid as I’d like to put my leading bid up for them to see

1: trades/viewtrade.php?id=111265771&userid=1017560&signature=-Yur0ZBWhVF6ccjjjTUNuw

2: trades/viewtrade.php?id=111290069&userid=1017560&signature=xVV8h0ffySDdkhcU7Np1qw

They seem pretty close to me with the first looking like it's a bit more, I think it depends if you want smaller rare bulk or something more valuable like the tree. The tree doesn't have great demand though and will be harder to trade off so if you don't plan on keeping it I'm not sure I'd accept that offer, but it's all subjective! Totally up to you haha.

Hope I didn't count totally wrong... Definitely get a second opinion.

Thank you! This does help! If anyone has a second opinion I’d love to hear it!

[saturnalia]

Help with this please?

[Konata.]

Hey guys I have two bids that I’m not 100% sure the value on, I know the first one will be a lil over 1.5Nons from the UR but I just want to know which one would be the better bid as I’d like to put my leading bid up for them to see

1: trades/viewtrade.php?id=111265771&userid=1017560&signature=-Yur0ZBWhVF6ccjjjTUNuw

2: trades/viewtrade.php?id=111290069&userid=1017560&signature=xVV8h0ffySDdkhcU7Np1qw

They seem pretty close to me with the first looking like it's a bit more, I think it depends if you want smaller rare bulk or something more valuable like the tree. The tree doesn't have great demand though and will be harder to trade off so if you don't plan on keeping it I'm not sure I'd accept that offer, but it's all subjective! Totally up to you haha.

Hope I didn't count totally wrong... Definitely get a second opinion.

Thank you! This does help! If anyone has a second opinion I’d love to hear it!

Hii second opinion here- personally I prefer the first trade as I don't like trading off the list. From my experiences trading bulk rares for lists doesn't really happen unless you find the right players. You're gonna have to trade a lot to work your way back up for list pets (esp since the second trade is offering a lot of more recent rares). If bulk rares is what you're looking for then by all means feel free to rank the bids based off your preferences

Help with this please?

Unfair to you, don't think their pet is even worth 1 of your store birds