The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SilverSpark]

Need a second opinion on this one ;;;

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111173502&userid=710102&signature=mNK7NgxwwdbrFVJkn9TUew

[EchothroughDarkness]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111184950&userid=410864&signature=Jc1KdqCFAhiIGSW0ROVIww

Add
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111185339&userid=410864&signature=C3lUslyb2YUP6RGCXaBWgg

[clarkal]

I was offered a green toxic RR for the set of 2012 store alien dogs plus a tier 5 purple husky, is this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111183374&userid=343527&signature=L1ih1p0tosnGZB313U5G1g

[Dogjelly]

I have no clue about older rare+ trades work so any help with this trade is appreciated!!
Thank you for your time!

[eelsyrup]

Could someone help me with this? I know rats aren't in the higjest demand but I'm not sure how a 2009 VR (among others) compares to a 2022 Store

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111184767&userid=1043699&signature=EpW2OFloHFKxLuE2AgwG5A

[Audrey_Bee]

Could someone help me with this? I know rats aren't in the higjest demand but I'm not sure how a 2009 VR (among others) compares to a 2022 Store

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111184767&userid=1043699&signature=EpW2OFloHFKxLuE2AgwG5A

It would be unfair, your rat is worth triple the value of the store pet alone. I'd probably take 2 old rares at the very least for the rat, personally, demand wise. So with demand I think they're still offering way less

[Faybell]

So I know this is most likely unfair by quite a bit to my side but is it worth trying to fix? If so any idea how to? Like how many sets of the new store pets is the evil pps worth?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111174666&userid=114864&signature=5J4Xi0gtbWKBISk28krpNg

[BeetleDragon]

Just got this trade, I’ve been trying to get rid of the butterfly wolf but I’m not sure if this is fair

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111183043&userid=1089621&signature=bLZKGWR-DpknMO7g19TCmA

[CloudFyre]

I have no clue about older rare+ trades work so any help with this trade is appreciated!!
Thank you for your time!

Horror's list has the Sunflower Rat at Tier 7 = 4-5 Old Rares === 2 08-'11 Very Rares so it's somewhere between being fair and the bwolves/dog being overpay depending on how you feel imo.

I was offered a green toxic RR for the set of 2012 store alien dogs plus a tier 5 purple husky, is this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111183374&userid=343527&signature=L1ih1p0tosnGZB313U5G1g

Green Toxic is 5 MA, purple husky and alien dogs are 1 MA each, looks fair~

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111184950&userid=410864&signature=Jc1KdqCFAhiIGSW0ROVIww

Add
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111185339&userid=410864&signature=C3lUslyb2YUP6RGCXaBWgg

1st: Coontail(2n) + (RR) BA(1n) then the Gray AWD is a regular VR = 3n
2nd: Nonjewel(1n) + UR Smore (1.5n) + UR Avocado(0.5n-0.75n) + Ghost Cat(1 MA) = ~3.3n

Looking at successful trades, the UR Flower Dragon has been going for 3-4n, so they're okay but you could likely get more

Need a second opinion on this one ;;;

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111173502&userid=710102&signature=mNK7NgxwwdbrFVJkn9TUew

The Snowflake Bwolf is worth 1MA or 10 old rares, their 2 store pets are 2 old rares each. The malk fox has good demand, although the rest can't really be considered "old rares" ('10/'11), I'd maybe say 1-3 depending on how you like to add it up, so I'd say it's unfair to you.

[clarkal]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111186867&userid=343527&signature=4DwUlniv5v-LNa6Ircmiug
I can find the values but How does this add up demand wise? Not sure if the tribal is hard to trade away or not as i wouldn’t be keeping it but trading for the pets on my wishlist