The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[bsideyarn]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110581574&userid=618963&signature=2twenHJchn8Oj9z0h5qIhw

is this a fair trade?

[warriorgirl13]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110604828&userid=119142&signature=Km6kDECt8KWY4gBwA6qfow

Any help would be awesome! I love the balloon dogs but I'm a little nervous to trade so many rare pets all at once (75 total on my side) but I also want to make sure the values match up to the balloon dog values, so please let me know if this is fair to both of us! Thank you!

[Veneti]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110604828&userid=119142&signature=Km6kDECt8KWY4gBwA6qfow

Any help would be awesome! I love the balloon dogs but I'm a little nervous to trade so many rare pets all at once (75 total on my side) but I also want to make sure the values match up to the balloon dog values, so please let me know if this is fair to both of us! Thank you! :D

Balloon dogs are worth 5MA each
5MA+5MA = 1N
1N=10MA=100 Old Rares

Dark Vollie Extended Release into 2009 - 2008 VR = 2.5 Old Rares
Light Fronted Vollie Extended Release into 2009 - 2008 VR = 2.5 Old Rares
Royal Star Dog Extended Release into 2009 - 2008 VR = 2.5 Old Rares
Brown Cookie Advent 2008 OMGSR - 1MA - 10 Old Rares
Bright Pointy Blue Leopard 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Brown Siamese 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Gray Siamese 2009 ER - 4-5 Old Rares
Coraline PPS 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
White Malk Toyger 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
White Malk Toyger 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Lime Sortic 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Purple Sortic 2009 ER - 5-7 Old Rares
Blue Sortic 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
White Sortic 2009 ER - 4-5 Old Rares
Orange Sortic 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Gray Yinyang 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Glowing Yinyang 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Blue Kala 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Orange Headed Kala 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Yinyang PPS 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Music PPS 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Ghost Cat 2009 ER - 10 Old Rares
09 Staff Dog 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Lioness (idk name) 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Pumpkin Pie PPS 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Pumpkin Dog 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Evil Lion 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Sabertooth Lioness 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Ghost PPS 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Socklion 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Glacier Lion 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Glowing Yinyang Lion 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Ghost Dog 2010 R - 1 Old Rare
Orange Sortic 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares

Imma just add the rest
2012 fodder - 1 MA - 10 Old Rares
Red X = 2MA - 20 Old Rares
Koi Dog family 0.5 Each - 15 Old Rares (STORE)
Cheetah - 0.5MA - 5 Old Rares (STORE)
2016 - 0.001 MA
Carnival Lions - 3-4 Old Rares Each - 16 Old Rares (STORE)
Pale Spotted Advent - 1MA - 10 Old Rares

Total = 180 Old Rares = 18MA which is way over 1N
So you would be overpaying by 8MA or 80 Old Rares

Please someone double check my math
This is going off of Horror's Guide

[Dappled_pony]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110610795&userid=578819&signature=3rrXNV2g6GiGc-cfcasF8g

99% sure this is fair! Can I Get a quick second opinion ? thank u!!

[Brienne of Tarth]

yellow sorbet for td red rose dog or nontag for td red rose dog

1 i know they're both .5n, but i do not keep up with the sorbet demand, plus since the red rose is a td, I'm just not sure? just would like a second opinion (:

and 2nd i just don't know the nontag demand/which would be better to trade off

[madeth]

looking for some feedback on this trade - the bunny is very high demand, but i still wanna check that this seems fair for its demand??
help appreciated!
solved - not fair, even with demand the bunny doesn't go for so much

[Rbpuppy]

yellow sorbet for td red rose dog or nontag for td red rose dog

1 i know they're both .5n, but i do not keep up with the sorbet demand, plus since the red rose is a td, I'm just not sure? just would like a second opinion (:

and 2nd i just don't know the nontag demand/which would be better to trade off

Commenting on the first trade here:
Personally I find that the sorbet has higher demand than the red rose, especially with the Sorbet holding that OMGSR value. Thought the TD aspect does give the red rose a higher value, personally I see that sorbet as more valuable and easier to trade off. However it all comes down to which one you like better!

[Audrey_Bee]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110610795&userid=578819&signature=3rrXNV2g6GiGc-cfcasF8g

99% sure this is fair! Can I Get a quick second opinion ? thank u!!

Yeah! Your side is 3MA,
The purple sleipnir can fetch between 0.25-0.5 nons so I'd say its fair /overpay.

I would say to think on if you're happy with it. I've recently traded two purple sleipnirs for 0.5 non each, however I did get some people refuse to value it that high because they still value it at its lowest value of 0.25 non, which didn't happen massively often.
Even at a fair 3MA worth, your store pets would have the higher demand. But considering the sleipnir can still fetch the higher range of 0.5non is the reason I would say this is fair. But it does depend on where on the scale you personally value the sleipnir !

[kitty teeth]

Is this fair? I don't know anything about items

[GhostPants]

Not too familiar with some of these items,how does it look?
@ghostpants