The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Andgora]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110590897&userid=918941&signature=knhNdT98e8B9_GTs0gVWHg

what about this one?:}

bump

[kitty teeth]

Is this fair? I don't know anything about items

TIA ♡ !

[GhostPants]

Not too familiar with some of these items,how does it look?
EDIT: This one too =) Another item trade
@ghostpants

[Layla_Storm01]

Could I get a second opinion on this trade please? I get a little lost when it comes to larger trades.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110633089&userid=935420&signature=wDFJ23pk25LWsHdGi4zgKw

Thank you!

[See_Air_Ruhh_]

So I've been tentatively looking at offers for my UR Flower Dragon and was curious how these looked?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110548960&userid=115676&signature=uhcxQX7Ci3uDpbRT2tk7qg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110371254&userid=115676&signature=zOMwKlsl687NS_7G0_G8RA

Would love a second opinion on these!

[warriorgirl13]

THANK YOU SO MUCH!!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110604828&userid=119142&signature=Km6kDECt8KWY4gBwA6qfow

Any help would be awesome! I love the balloon dogs but I'm a little nervous to trade so many rare pets all at once (75 total on my side) but I also want to make sure the values match up to the balloon dog values, so please let me know if this is fair to both of us! Thank you!

Balloon dogs are worth 5MA each
5MA+5MA = 1N
1N=10MA=100 Old Rares

Dark Vollie Extended Release into 2009 - 2008 VR = 2.5 Old Rares
Light Fronted Vollie Extended Release into 2009 - 2008 VR = 2.5 Old Rares
Royal Star Dog Extended Release into 2009 - 2008 VR = 2.5 Old Rares
Brown Cookie Advent 2008 OMGSR - 1MA - 10 Old Rares
Bright Pointy Blue Leopard 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Brown Siamese 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Gray Siamese 2009 ER - 4-5 Old Rares
Coraline PPS 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
White Malk Toyger 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
White Malk Toyger 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Lime Sortic 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Purple Sortic 2009 ER - 5-7 Old Rares
Blue Sortic 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
White Sortic 2009 ER - 4-5 Old Rares
Orange Sortic 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Gray Yinyang 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Glowing Yinyang 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Blue Kala 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Orange Headed Kala 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Yinyang PPS 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Music PPS 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Ghost Cat 2009 ER - 10 Old Rares
09 Staff Dog 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Lioness (idk name) 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares
Pumpkin Pie PPS 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Pumpkin Dog 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Evil Lion 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Sabertooth Lioness 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Ghost PPS 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Socklion 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Glacier Lion 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Glowing Yinyang Lion 2010 VR - 2 Old Rares
Ghost Dog 2010 R - 1 Old Rare
Orange Sortic 2009 VR - 2.5 Old Rares

Imma just add the rest
2012 fodder - 1 MA - 10 Old Rares
Red X = 2MA - 20 Old Rares
Koi Dog family 0.5 Each - 15 Old Rares (STORE)
Cheetah - 0.5MA - 5 Old Rares (STORE)
2016 - 0.001 MA
Carnival Lions - 3-4 Old Rares Each - 16 Old Rares (STORE)
Pale Spotted Advent - 1MA - 10 Old Rares

Total = 180 Old Rares = 18MA which is way over 1N
So you would be overpaying by 8MA or 80 Old Rares

Please someone double check my math
This is going off of Horror's Guide

[Nikki6Ashba]

yellow sorbet for td red rose dog or nontag for td red rose dog

1 i know they're both .5n, but i do not keep up with the sorbet demand, plus since the red rose is a td, I'm just not sure? just would like a second opinion (:

and 2nd i just don't know the nontag demand/which would be better to trade off

I'm the other side of the nontag trade, I'm also curious

[sweetpepper]

1. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110635117&userid=763102&signature=O-jUPqt4iYyjlyHtSVVbTw
how is this? i believe i could edit their side if need be ^^
2. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110602454&userid=763102&signature=7MuBGLOQS0vI2e2bipGLxA
i'd also like any input on this pls!

[jointedwishes]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110636151&userid=961979&signature=Lv5HeMHqe1YzkKLLh_Q9zg

thoughts on this small item trade?:)

[reflections.]

Is there any special worth to this animal egg? Thank you.