The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ephemural]

this really doesnt feel fair, but please please please lmk if it is..

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110629787&userid=1005158&signature=XvD-Cs4NyAs08EX1J6OBmg

[kitty teeth]

Is this fair? I don't know anything about items

TIA ♡ !

[mothmun]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110584753&userid=654443&signature=BSemBOeRox-Sb9d2_9iumw

hello! i dont know much about the value of the warriors cats and i think this is one so i thought i'd check,,,

[5parrow]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110630797&userid=728148&signature=zk7MIo-ajGdkIEy0Sc5uDw

Is this fair? I can't tell because their nonrarities and event pets.

[Ishnawababa]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110630797&userid=728148&signature=zk7MIo-ajGdkIEy0Sc5uDw

Is this fair? I can't tell because their nonrarities and event pets.

I'm going to say overpay. Token event pets are generally rare or extremely uncommon. The blue cow, even though many people are looking for it, I doubt will be more than an uncommon since it is a free release pet. 6 2024 rares don't add up to two 2010 rares + extras + 15 c$

[5parrow]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110584753&userid=654443&signature=BSemBOeRox-Sb9d2_9iumw

hello! i dont know much about the value of the warriors cats and i think this is one so i thought i'd check,,,

I would say no, just because none of the pets are within reasonable years and also their rarities do not match the demand of the pet. Warrior cats are in high demand on the website.

[Delta Dawn]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110584753&userid=654443&signature=BSemBOeRox-Sb9d2_9iumw

hello! i dont know much about the value of the warriors cats and i think this is one so i thought i'd check,,,

Warrior cats go for .5 MA or 5 old rares ('10 - '11) so this is unfair to your cat. They'd need to add 3-4 '10 or '11 rares

this really doesnt feel fair, but please please please lmk if it is..

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110629787&userid=1005158&signature=XvD-Cs4NyAs08EX1J6OBmg

It's not horribly unfair if you use the 1:2 rule, but if you don't want to trade that much for a single pet you don't have to! At the end of the day trading is entirely up to preferences.

[GhostPants]

Not too familiar with some of these items,how does it look?
EDIT: This one too =) Another item trade
@ghostpants

[Animooser]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110594964&userid=329114&signature=CTtI6LN7rmpNYbDGcicHbQ

If anyone can help me witht he item values, im not sure if its fair.

[Fluffle puffle]

Opinions on this one?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110529679&userid=822924&signature=AucnovG8PrmlNpdzfU9fuA